We're getting there! There are currently 793 philosophy articles [1] better than C-class in Wikipedia.
By quality:
* Featured articles: 41 [2]
* Featured lists: 4 [3]
* Good articles: 113 [4]
* B-class articles: 635 [5]
1. Summary table of philosophy articles by quality and importance: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Philosophy_articles_b...
2. https://tools.wmflabs.org/enwp10/cgi-bin/list2.fcgi?run=yes&...
3. https://tools.wmflabs.org/enwp10/cgi-bin/list2.fcgi?run=yes&...
4. https://tools.wmflabs.org/enwp10/cgi-bin/list2.fcgi?run=yes&...
5. https://tools.wmflabs.org/enwp10/cgi-bin/list2.fcgi?run=yes&...
But I use them both, for different things. The general overview articles are much better at SEP than Wikipedia. But Wikipedia has a lot more narrow articles, on subjects that SEP doesn't cover at all, or mentions only in passing in one paragraph of an article. For example, a huge number of short-to-medium-length biographies of historically important philosophers (SEP instead has a small number of quite lengthy biographies).
I do wish something like SEP existed in more other fields. I don't know of anything like it for computer science, for example.
My impression is that in many cases this is because there were multiple major authors without a master plan for writing the article, so they ended up sort of putting it all in.
For someone (like me!) who's struggling to grasp a subject, seeing a subject described from multiple points of views, targeting varying levels of expertise, can be immensely helpful.
A traditional encyclopedia article, on the other hand, is probably more likely to be well-structured and comprehensive, but ... I think can be harder to grasp for someone that's not quite up to the material.
It may be kind of ugly, but the "Just throw it all in!" approach does have some real merit...
"complete; including all or nearly all elements or aspects of something"
What's not fair is comparing SEP to Wikipedia, which is a different thing. SEP and Wikipedia have entirely different problems to optimise for.
SEP can optimise for article authoritivity & comprehensivity because the rate at which new articles are added is much, much, much, lower than Wikipedia's. SEP don't have an article for new movie releases, books, actors, current affairs.
I have to confess I think the comparison between the two is somewhat disengenuous.
It's like comparing databases that make different CAP theorem trade-offs (and are designed for different scales) in a situation that's favourable to one of them, and reporting it as a fair and objective comparison... I hesitate to give an example because it may start a flamewar, but [dons flame-retardant underpants] it's like saying that SQLite is objectively better than CouchDB because SQLite doesn't have consistency issues.
SEP's model would fall flat on its face if were expected to do Wikipedia's job.
If we're talking all philosophy articles in all 291 Wikipedias [2], and (generously) assume that the average Wikipedia has 10% as many philosophy-related articles as English Wikipedia, that's 19,339 * 0.10 * 291 = 562,764 philosophy articles on all Wikipedias. That's 3 orders of magnitude more than SEP's 1,500 articles -- although that's not really comparing apples to apples as we're comparing many languages to one.
1. See Total x Total cell at lower right in matrix at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Philosophy_articles_b...
Another example might be, A correct compiler can compile any valid program. It's all encompassing. An optimizing compiler, that's can't handle template syntax is more comprehensive. Better answers in a narrower field. Finally the template aware optimizing compiler is all-encompassing and more comprehensive.
Wikipedia is extremely broad. According to the article, the SEP has 1500 entries. Each of those is no doubt better than an individual Wikipedia article (more cohesive, more in-depth, etc), but I bet there's two orders of magnitude more Wiki articles on philosophy (nevermind other topics!). It no doubt has much wider coverage. How's that for "more comprehensive"?
I guess I'm just complaining about stretching a word to mean something more specific than it usually means. I think of comprehensive as including both in-depth focus and wide-ranging reach. So when the article counts only one of those aspects, and omits the other from the checklist, it feels like cherry-picking the outcome.