News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Volkswagen Chief Martin Winterkorn Resigns Amid Emissions... by pc86 on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @12:14PM (#10265931)
He has said publicly that he is not aware of any wrong-doing on his part. I imagine that just about any board would require just about any CEO to resign after something like this, though.
Re:Volkswagen Chief Martin Winterkorn Resigns Amid Emissions... by Scramblejams on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @12:17PM (#10265952)
When it comes to a relatively new CEO, I'm not so sure about that. GM didn't require Mary Barra's resignation over the ignition switch scandal, for example. (Though admittedly that one was smaller than VW's.)

Edit: Winterkorn took over as chairman of the supervisory board of VW in April, but as petewailes pointed out, he's been CEO since 2007, so his resignation makes more sense.

Re:Volkswagen Chief Martin Winterkorn Resigns Amid Emissions... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @12:21PM (#10265975)
Is it the difference between deliberate/undefendable and simple cost savings? I'm not very familiar with the switch issue.
Re:Volkswagen Chief Martin Winterkorn Resigns Amid Emissions... by mzs on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @02:18PM (#10266887)
The cost between GM and VW here is two orders of magnitude, the stock did not drop by a third, and the EPA and CARB were not involved.
Re:Volkswagen Chief Martin Winterkorn Resigns Amid Emissions... by duaneb on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @12:32PM (#10266058)
I would imagine at the level of management complexity, liability, and brand awareness of VW, which details get reported to whom becomes very important. He may have been technically unaware of cheating, for instance, but may have been aware of a "test optimizer".

This is about taking a fall. It's up to the courts (I assume, American, not German) to establish how much he is actually at fault. But the idea that they sold 11M vehicles with hardware cheating the emissions test makes his claim fairly absurd. That kind of decision has got to be made at a high level, even if it's just choosing different budgets without looking closely.

Re:Volkswagen Chief Martin Winterkorn Resigns Amid Emissions... by msandford on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @12:59PM (#10266240)
> But the idea that they sold 11M vehicles with hardware cheating the emissions test makes his claim fairly absurd.

So a CEO must know every detail about every component of every subsystem of every system in every trim level of every car of every brand that the company sells?

If that's really true, we're headed back to the early industrial revolution. Nothing can have more than a few dozen or perhaps hundred parts, and integration of say electronics and mechanical things will be rare, as it'll be the rare CEO who knows enough about both to meet your standard.

Re:Volkswagen Chief Martin Winterkorn Resigns Amid Emissions... by wpietri on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @01:14PM (#10266361)
No. But broadly, a CEO is responsible for everything that happens on their watch. And they are specifically responsible for designing their organizations in such a way that the organization behaves responsibly.

Ignorance cannot be an excuse for bad management. If we allow that, then executives can set things up so that they always appear ignorant. E.g., imagine a CEO says, "I don't care how you dispose of that toxic waste, just make sure that it's cheap. And of course it has to be safe [wink, wink]. Just don't bother me with details [wink, wink]." Any employee will know the real message.

Re:Volkswagen Chief Martin Winterkorn Resigns Amid Emissions... by nmrm2 on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @01:43PM (#10266588)
Right, like the "GM nod".

The principle that CEOs are responsible for what happens on their watch is major reason cited for their levels of compensation. You don't get it both ways.

Re:Volkswagen Chief Martin Winterkorn Resigns Amid Emissions... by wpietri on Thursday September 24, 2015 @10:46AM (#10271884)
Holy moly. I had missed reports of the "GM nod" and their cultural pathologies. What an enormous mess. 95% of people's smarts taken up with performing rituals that shield them from blame. All real communication is sub-rosa, with actual words said unrelated to meaning.

The detail that really kills me is that many employees thought that taking notes in meetings related to safety issues was forbidden. There was no official word of that, of course, but lots of people believed that following unofficial, gossip-routed information was the way to succeed in their careers. What lunacy. They should have been allowed to go bankrupt.

Re:Volkswagen Chief Martin Winterkorn Resigns Amid Emissions... by msandford on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @02:37PM (#10267054)
I completely agree! It doesn't matter if this particular CEO knew about this particular detail, because ultimately they're responsible for the culture, the work environment, etc. If they made a bad work environment at the top, and that trickled down to someone deciding to go the cheat route rather than the honest route, that's a problem.

If the CEO did things right and made a good work environment but hired a bad exec, and they applied pressure to people to cheat, and this all got done, again, can be traced back to the CEO.

If the CEO did the right thing and hired a seemingly great exec and that exec hired a bad manager, well, perhaps the CEO didn't do such an exceptional job.

Ultimately all organizational failures like this are failures of management, and the CEO is the top manager so it's all on him (or her) when things go sideways.

But just because it's all on them doesn't mean that we can all safely conclude that they definitely had firsthand personal knowledge of the problem and gave their approval, explicit, implicit or otherwise.

Re:Volkswagen Chief Martin Winterkorn Resigns Amid Emissions... by emodendroket on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:08PM (#10268257)
Hey, it worked for Steve Cohen.
Re:Volkswagen Chief Martin Winterkorn Resigns Amid Emissions... by JustSomeNobody on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @01:44PM (#10266599)
> So a CEO must know every detail about every component of every subsystem of every system in every trim level of every car of every brand that the company sells?

Of course, not. Stop trying to change the argument.

He would know that VW cars are getting better scores than other cars. These are numbers that CEOs and other managerial positions live for. He would know why. Though he may not understand the technical details of why.

Re:Volkswagen Chief Martin Winterkorn Resigns Amid Emissions... by msandford on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @02:32PM (#10267018)
> Of course, not. Stop trying to change the argument.

I'm not trying to change the argument. I'm taking your statement literally, and showing that it's entirely unworkable in practice. I'm not saying he shouldn't be fired or have to step down, but to presume that he personally, definitely knew is quite the leap. I can think of several scenarios where he didn't know and is entirely innocent which are quite plausible.

I also think that regardless of whether he personally had knowledge of exactly what was being done or not, he still created a work environment which rewarded the shortcut and the cheat over the right thing and needs to go. But that's an entirely different line of reasoning than "he must have known!" as a justification.

> He would know that VW cars are getting better scores than other cars. These are numbers that CEOs and other managerial positions live for. He would know why. Though he may not understand the technical details of why.

No, not necessarily. You're making an awful lot of assumptions and none of them are even superficially argued, much less backed up by verification. This isn't CO2 where you can draw a pretty clear line correlation between fuel efficiency and CO2 emissions. This is NO2 emissions which are highly variable and depend on a great many factors. So it's entirely possible that for the same CO2 emissions one car might output far more NO2 than another.

https://www.quora.com/Why-does-diesel-exhaust-contain-more-n...

I'm very sympathetic to the notion of "if you get to claim credit for the good, then you're also going to be held responsible for the bad" argument, generally I agree with it. This is not an exceptional case. But to argue that because this is a reasonable course of action, that the person in charge of a 500k employee company must have known a particular detail of a particular subsystem? Not reasonable. Not defending the person, the company, the actions, or anything like that but I am attacking your reasoning.

Re:Volkswagen Chief Martin Winterkorn Resigns Amid Emissions... by JustSomeNobody on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:00PM (#10268174)
Reread what I said:

"He would know that VW cars are getting better scores than other cars. These are numbers that CEOs and other managerial positions live for."

Yes. He would know this. I'm not saying he would know or understand the actual technical details (NO2 parts per billion vs other carmakers results).

In fact, I said this, " He would know why. Though he may not understand the technical details of why."

He would know why they are getting better results. "Oh, we tweaked the firmware and now we're in compliance."

There are no superficial assumptions here. CEOs are NOT that detached. And people are going to tell them things. And they are going to ask questions. They aren't fools.

Re:Volkswagen Chief Martin Winterkorn Resigns Amid Emissions... by msandford on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:48PM (#10269550)
> He would know why. Though he may not understand the technical details of why." He would know why they are getting better results. "Oh, we tweaked the firmware and now we're in compliance."

Yes, precisely my point. If he knew that they "tweaked the firmware" well there's a million ways to do that legally and to be in compliance. And there seem to be a few ways you can do it illegally too, and no be in compliance.

The claim he made was "He has said publicly that he is not aware of any wrong-doing on his part." And that's technically true! Hiring someone who punches another employee reflects poorly on you, but that doesn't make the punch your fault. So hiring someone who hired someone who hired someone who told a programmer to come up with a "cheat mode" hardly makes the CEO directly responsible. He is responsible through the chain of command, but not because of direct knowledge.

Finally, please remember that emissions are incredibly complex and it's entirely possible that someday someone will discover a way to get great mileage with low NOx emissions. Maybe it's pulsed injection, maybe it's having more fuel injectors, maybe it's even higher pressures, maybe it's who knows what. So just because you're getting numbers that are better than your competitors doesn't automatically mean that the people in your company must be cheating and that they need to be found out. It's entirely likely that they just did something clever!