Customers are totally not interested in the fact that some other random customer may not be experiencing problems and that amazon has a wide variety of services, some of which may not be affected in certain geographies. Customers go to that panel with one express goal: to discover if the problems they are seeing with their servers could be related to them. It is a triage check. The question is not, is Amazon super great and are the availability engineers the bestest on average over time? The question is, what the fuck is going on?
Amazon has suffered catastrophic unavailability, and the green-i has appeared belatedly, an hour or more into the problem. Because as revealed in this post, it is manually put up by engineers. Manually!
Manually!
In your hypothetical scenario, the customer that is going to the panel to "find out what the fuck is going on" is not going to miss the indicator i, and will read the description of the message.
That's absolutely not what it means practically for any of the recent outages. It has come to mean "the service is down but not hard enough for us to admit it".
Yeah, a small green-i should cover it.
Green-i: Some small percentage of customers are affected, but most of you have nothing to worry about. So if you are a customer having problems and see this notice, you are re-assured that you are not crazy. And if you are NOT seeing problems, you probably won't. Amazon has not always been the best at posting this information quickly enough, hence a commitment to be better at messaging for those customers
Yellow: A significant amount of customers is affected. Potentially serious problems, and if you haven't seen them yet, don't be surprised if you will. Start monitoring your service health and preparing for a failover to another region.
Red: FUBAR. Happens rarely, but when it does you'll probably know even before your application alarms - you'll notice when half the internet shuts down.