Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules
by phkahler on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:01AM
(#10265007)
>> The claim is not really about "motivating" people to create, but making it easier to make a living off their works.
Ask a random author, musician, or artist how easy it is to make a living, and how much copyright law helps them. And if you do get a positive response, ask how having it apply for more than 10 years helps them.
Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules
by SarahofGaia on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:40AM
(#10265249)
> And if you do get a positive response, ask how having it apply for more than 10 years helps them.
They did say, "most studies are more about how much copyright protection is enough", to be accurate. :/
Re:'Happy Birthday' song copyright is not valid, judge rules
by throwawaykf05 on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @03:01PM
(#10267268)
Right, most studies don't question the need for copyright at all, just how it should be tweaked to be optimal.
There are studies on these kinds of things. The picture is quite complex for patent systems, where economists struggle to prove whether we're better off with them or we'd be better off without them. There is no such question about the need for a copyright system though -- most studies are more about how much copyright protection is enough.