News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by jacquesm on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:11PM (#10261736)
One more reason for publishing the source code to drive-line software in cars. And don't give me nonsense about 'millions of lines of code' (I've heard that before in another context too), an ECU is not 'millions of lines of code'.

And as far as VW is concerned this is only the beginning: how many customers are going to sue VW for a sudden decrease in market value / resale value of their vehicle?

The damage to the VW brand is enormous, if not fatal. But the damage to 'Made in Germany' and the rest of the German brands is collosal as well. This will surely be reflected in the GDP of Germany for many years to come.

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by PhantomGremlin on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:49PM (#10261952)
The damage to the VW brand is enormous, if not fatal.

GM recently admitted that a defective product of theirs was responsible for over 120 deaths:

   General Motors agreed to pay $900 million as
   part of a Justice Department investigation
   into its failure to fix a deadly ignition
   switch defect blamed for more than 120 deaths.[1]
Nobody seems to care, except for a few lawyers and the victims' families. GM is still in business, current market cap $47 billion.

It would be a tragedy if the cost to VW of their negligence is more than the cost to GM of theirs.

And in response to those who say that increased pollution could kill a lot more, I acknowledge the hypothetical. But in my mind, the death of 120 identified people with names, children, friends, aspirations, etc, is far worse than the increased NOx from VW's cars.

[1] http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2015/09/17/gm-justi...

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by setpatchaddress on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @07:28PM (#10262436)
You're missing some important context. GM is long-established in America. (So is Toyota.) VW's current market penetration in America is pretty minimal. And all Volkswagens are sold with a premium sales pitch, if not premium price points.

Now all VW diesel cars sold during a certain period will have their resale value greatly reduced. Non-diesel VW resale values will be tainted at least slightly by association. Even if VW recalls the cars and replaces them with a completely overhauled diesel drivetrain -- very unlikely -- there will still be a massive class action lawsuit, because the car will not be working as advertised in some way. This will keep potential buyers away from showrooms.

It's really not hyperbole.

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by PhantomGremlin on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @08:11PM (#10262593)
VW's current market penetration in America is pretty minimal.

That's true, but it's not because they aren't "long established". E.g. I personally owned the 1966 version of this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagon_beetle so that's 50 years right there.

I'm sure it goes back quite a way further than that, but, after a quick scan of that Wiki, I couldn't find the original date that imports started.

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by ArkyBeagle on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @08:57PM (#10262742)
There are model year 1948 Beetles in the U.S. These may have been shipped outside a dealer network.
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by jacquesm on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @06:05PM (#10262027)
Calling this negligence is way too nice.
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by trhway on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @06:35PM (#10262181)
opening scenes of "Fight Club" pretty much explain that there is no "negligence", there is only "cost"
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by inversionOf on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @06:35PM (#10262177)
The GM issue was enormous for literally years. Further the GM issue -- where key assembly had less torsion than expected, leading to the possibility of heavy keychains or unintended hits turning off the vehicle -- was never shown to be anything more than an isolated engineering mistake by a few engineers, who then actively covered up their own mistake. GM wasn't profiteering by having less tension than expected -- it didn't sell them cars, and it didn't save them money. The malice was not profiteering or circumventing. And for that they paid a $900 million dollar fine, and will pay out billions in lawsuits in virtually any case where the key turned off, even if it was actually operator error.

GM is in no universe blameless, but considerations that hold it like murder are irrational.

VW actively and intentionally misled consumers and regulators to sell cars promising mileage and power levels they don't actually achieve without actually cheating the system. They sold hundreds of thousands of cars -- at the cost of significant air pollution (some 200,000 Americans, and millions worldwide, are estimated to die from air pollution yearly) -- based upon these essentially lies. They actively promoted their eco-friendliness, and their great fuel economy, neither of which are actually true in concert.

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by tetrep on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:27PM (#10261821)
> One more reason for publishing the source code to drive-line software in cars.

How does this prevent VW from publishing inaccurate source code?

Let's say we manage to force them to not only disclose full source code but also how to make binary reproducible builds and we also (somehow) can verify the integrity of every single microcontroller in the car, how do we prevent underhanded programming tactics?

We're always going to need to trust auto makers so why put massive burdens on them that don't remove our need to trust them?

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by jacquesm on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:32PM (#10261853)
Well, I'd assume that someone will take that sourcecode, compile it and run it and spot the differences which will lead to speedy publication of evidence of foul play.
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by dclowd9901 on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:35PM (#10261872)
Publishing source code is not a massive burden. Developers do it all day long every day.
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by yrro on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:56PM (#10261989)
They should be required to come up with a build system that produces reproducible output, then people can dump the code in their car and compare it to what was published.
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by Retra on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @07:02PM (#10262289)
If you can dump the code in your car, then you can boost your own car's performance by circumventing the laws yourself. That's one of the reasons this software is locked up, (as I understand it, anyway)
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by jacquesm on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @07:06PM (#10262308)
You can swap out your tires for known good ones just before the MOT too and swap them back afterwards. Laws can always be circumvented, but that does not make such circumvention any less illegal and when caught the penalties tend to be quite serious.
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by letstryagain on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @07:20PM (#10262386)
You can do that anyway, and some people do in fact replace their controller chips with modified clones to boost performance.

http://www.chipexpress.com/

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by Skunkleton on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:33PM (#10261861)
Open hardware designs would resolve this issue. If you were so inclined, you could re-implement your computers electronics based on the specification. Unfortunately I don’t see this ever happening.
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by x0x0 on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @06:10PM (#10262055)
When Hyundai got caught exaggerating the mileage of their 2011 - 2013 model year vehicles, as a settlement they are paying a reimbursement equal to the cost of the gas to cover the difference plus a 15% premium for the lifetime of the vehicles [1]. If, as is widely speculated, the only way to make the VWs as clean as necessary reduces mileage, VW will probably be on the hook for similar reimbursements.

[1] https://hyundaimpginfo.com/customerinfo/compensation-informa...

edits: grammar. apparently I can't write coherently today.

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by arbitrage on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:26PM (#10261811)
Fatal? Please, you're exaggerating greatly. If the pinto couldn't kill Ford, VW will be just fine.
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by jacquesm on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:37PM (#10261884)
VW has a ton of brands besides just the main one and this affects a very large number of vehicles and an equally large number of customers. I've been a pretty loyal VW customer for the last 8 years and my next car will definitely not be a VW, this is unacceptable at just about every level and I'm fairly sure I'm not the only person thinking like this.

If you think VW will be just fine now would be a good time to buy some stock.

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by CamperBob2 on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:46PM (#10261936)
I'd wait for the other shoe to drop. The other shoe being the fantastic unlikelihood that VW is the only automaker pulling crap like this, or even one of a minority of manufacturers.

This story isn't over yet, I'm pretty sure of that.

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by mcguire on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @06:28PM (#10262142)
My suspicion is that the first other shoe to drop is that VW's gag affected European emissions testing, as well. Diesel cars are a pretty small minority in the US; in Europe, they're much more popular and a much larger chunk of VW's sales.

On the other hand, I can almost hear the other manufacturer's executives scrambling around asking, "Are we being this blatant?" and I'm quite a few miles from any segment of the automotive industry.

(Disclosure: I have a 2002 Corvette with the CAGS disabled.)

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by makomk on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:24AM (#10264047)
One of the reasons diesels are more popular in Europe than the US is that US emissions standards are a lot harder to pass for diesels than they are for petrol cars and always have been.
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by jacquesm on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @06:04PM (#10262022)
At this point that would be a god-send for VW. The stock market seems to agree with you by the way.
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by CamperBob2 on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @06:55PM (#10262252)
Yes, the fact that the whistle wasn't blown by VW's competitors -- who you can rest assured knew what was going on -- is pretty ominous.
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by hnal943 on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:30PM (#10261834)
Well, it's not just one model, it's all the small TDI's. According to what I've read, that's a pretty big segment of their American market. How important is America to an auto manufacturer?
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by rconti on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:34PM (#10261865)
It's like 15% of their US market. But the 11 million figure in this article (vs the old 450k figure) includes vehicles worldwide. 450k was US diesels from VW.
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by bshimmin on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:26PM (#10261818)
In the UK cars are taxed according to their emissions - will VW have to foot the bill for the problems this will cause their customers?
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by jacquesm on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:35PM (#10261870)
Since this is clearly malicious intent on the part of VW that the customers if and when presented with a bill from Her Majesty's collection agency will be in an excellent position to pass the buck to VW. After all it's in every advertisement they've ever made about these vehicles.

VW is in a world of trouble. This saddens me because our fleet has both a VW caravelle and a VW up, neither of which are affected but VW has been an excellent supplier for me to date and I'm seriously disappointed that they would stoop this low. Even if this order did not come from the top (which one would hope) it screams lack of oversight and lack of independent in-house verification.

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by ctz on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:36PM (#10261881)
They're taxed according to CO2 emissions rather than NOx (which is measured for European and Californian emissions requirements, and the subject of this dishonesty).

There's no reason the same method couldn't be used to falsify CO2 emissions (and therefore VED band) too though!

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by nsnick on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:52PM (#10261969)
I think if CO2 emissions were being gamed, we would see that the gasoline models were also affected.
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by aaron695 on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:45PM (#10261928)
> ECU is not 'millions of lines of code'.

So researchers magically know in what bit of code the next scandal will be?

Next time it might be the simulation software that's not even in the car. Lets release that to.

Or should we ask them to only release the exact bit of code with the issue?

Besides which, do we even get the EFF is not crazy enough to ask for them to publish their source code and destroy their IP?

They just don't want the anti-circumvention measures in the the DCMA to apply. The right to access what's in our hardware.

Not the right to force people and companies to do things they don't want to. This is not government run voting hardware.

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by jacquesm on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @06:09PM (#10262047)
> So researchers magically know in what bit of code the next scandal will be?

Emissions, performance and service related scandals will almost certainly not originate in the entertainment system or the navigation system.

Security issues might originate there if the other side is not properly designed.

So ECU, ABS, ODBII and such should be fair game and 'inspectable'.

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by scott_karana on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @01:24AM (#10263448)
Considering what we've heard about not-so-airgaps in Chrysler's hacked ECU + onboard entertainment systems, would it be so far-fetched that other systems would be used to game testing, if only ECUs were mandatory to be open? ;)
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by venomsnake on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:16PM (#10261762)
> One more reason for publishing the source code to drive-line software in cars. And don't give me nonsense about 'millions of lines of code' (I've heard that before in another context too), an ECU is not 'millions of lines of code'.

In that case we could have aftermarket parts and/or interoperability. These are bad things that could cut into corporate profits.

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by famousactress on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:27PM (#10261820)
> In that case we could have aftermarket parts and/or interoperability. These are bad things that could cut into corporate profits.

Evidence?

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by venomsnake on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @06:28PM (#10262143)
About sarcasm?
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by jacquesm on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:16PM (#10261768)
More than 16B worth of profits?
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by venomsnake on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:23PM (#10261797)
Well, getting caught is never part of the corporate strategy. You could always make the revolving door turn a liitle bit faster.

VW and BP spill are outliers.

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by superuser2 on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @06:12PM (#10262067)
Indeed. Once the cars have "emissions testing mode" turned on full-time, they're going to be a hell of a lot less fun to drive.
Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by kw71 on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @06:11PM (#10262061)
> One more reason for publishing the source code to drive-line software in cars.

There is no reason for anyone to publish their trade-secrets. Compliance can be assured through better testing, which is how this came to light.

All the arguments for open source in this market are wonky. They sum up to things like "I want to tamper with my engine controls because I somehow know more than the team of degreed engineers who designed it and got it type-approved" and "I want a generic ECU for all engines because it will be great if everyone had to pay for logic, drivers and other hardware that only a small subset of engines require. Oh and because it would be easier for me to tamper with."

I'm glad this situation came out into the press because it will discourage other carmakers from cheating.

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by jacquesm on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @06:15PM (#10262084)
Or: My life is on the line and I'd like to know what it is exactly that I'm driving. Or: my car does not seem to perform as advertised, is the ECU capable of switching modes in order to pass certain tests?

There are many reasons to want to inspect/build the code to the hardware that you already own.

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by kw71 on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @06:37PM (#10262191)
You (probably) and I are part of a small minority in the entire universe qualified to do such examination. A lot of bosch source codes got leaked, but if you have or want to write analysis tools for the TriCore ISA to inspect your VW's firmware, you can get the firmware from [1].

[1] http://rutracker.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=4996779

Re:VW emissions scandal hits 11m vehicles by jacquesm on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @07:04PM (#10262301)
It's pretty normal for any expertise to be limited to a 'small minority'. All it takes to expose trickery like this is for that small minority to do their thing and then write lay-man comprehensible press releases. This is how a lot of stuff gets exposed and for the most part that does not seem to require in-depth understanding of the nitty gritty details by the un-informed, even though they may be directly affected. (In this case: by higher fuel bills to date, reduced re-sale value and possibly a forced significant drop in performance).