Re:Rules for Open Source Success
by TuringTest on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @09:46AM
(#10258468)
Yes, maybe they would have released it, just like they released modified parts of FreeBSD. But the share-alike makes it less likely that they keep the best parts hidden, and more likely that there's a single reference implementation where improvements from competitors are kept close to one another.
WebKit did get released after the KDE developers attacked Apple for violating the license of KHTML.
Violating it? When did they ever do that, or get attacked for it?
They got complaints for just having code-dumps (or WebCore/JavaScriptCore) alongside releases, which made it hard to have any sort of individual patches. They were still in no way obliged to move to developing it in public, nor were they obliged to release WebKit.
Hmm. They may well have eventually released it — WebKit did eventually get released (years after the code dumps of WebCore an JavaScriptCore).