Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ...
by elblanco on Friday January 01, 2010 @09:33AM
(#1025704)
> Which you were, because you were attacking downvoters personally instead of their use of the downvote system.
Fair enough.
> I see; I thought you were offering an exhaustive list rather than the beginnings of a list.
Perhaps I should have followed with some ellipses "..."
> Can you back that up with anything? What 'consequences' should there be to downvoting things you don't want to see on a site built to be shaped by the voting of people who are present?
The suppression of dissenting and contradictory voices.
A comment like "downvoted because I disagree with your point about ..." creates value by focusing discussion on a particular area of interest. While just a downvote supplies nothing meaningful to the discussion and merely seeks to suppress some viewpoint in the most general sense.
A definition of discussion is "an exchange of views on some topic", suppressing alternate viewpoints does not lend itself to creating discussion.
Fair enough.
> I see; I thought you were offering an exhaustive list rather than the beginnings of a list.
Perhaps I should have followed with some ellipses "..."
> Can you back that up with anything? What 'consequences' should there be to downvoting things you don't want to see on a site built to be shaped by the voting of people who are present?
The suppression of dissenting and contradictory voices.
A comment like "downvoted because I disagree with your point about ..." creates value by focusing discussion on a particular area of interest. While just a downvote supplies nothing meaningful to the discussion and merely seeks to suppress some viewpoint in the most general sense.
A definition of discussion is "an exchange of views on some topic", suppressing alternate viewpoints does not lend itself to creating discussion.