News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unsolved problems with the common core by viraptor on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @02:27AM (#10256941)
I can't tell if this post is serious, or making fun of the topic. I got to the point where the author thinks it's a good idea to talk about graph k-colouring with kids in kindergarten. Does anyone think this can have any meaningful discussion beyond a "you can colour any map with 4 colours" trivia?

Just as a reminder, these are points from the grade k overview:

- Know number names and the count sequence.

- Count to tell the number of objects.

Re:Unsolved problems with the common core by Rusky on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @02:37AM (#10256966)
Getting kids to think about and experiment with graph coloring is probably a more reasonable and productive goal than trying to have a "meaningful discussion" about it with kindergarteners. It's certainly not something that stood out as ridiculous to me.
Re:Unsolved problems with the common core by baldfat on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @06:48AM (#10257756)
I work for Head Start and we actually have "meaningful" conversations with children about what interest them. Making math, engineering or science "interesting" is very natural for child. The hardest part is getting adults to think through those lens and break them down into simple interconnecting ideas to the child's world and help them learn new vocabulary. Kids are natural learners.
Re:Unsolved problems with the common core by aaron695 on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @06:27AM (#10257702)
http://www.pbs.org/parents/childdevelopmenttracker/five/math...

"At age five, some children may still be gaining an understanding of the number words up to "four" (e.g., distinguishes one-four items from "many"; can identify collections of up to four items with a corresponding number; asks for up to "four" of something; knows age; can put out "one," "two," "three," or "four" items upon request)."

So rather than setting a childs education backward and depress them with abstracts before nouns, when I read about it and understood the question at age 10 is was kinda a cool and interesting problem.

That's if you want to take the ages and article seriously, which the OP was asking if the original was. It being more a thought piece I suspect.

Re:Unsolved problems with the common core by viraptor on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @09:07AM (#10258277)
I think I didn't use the right phrase. I was thinking of something more general than discussion - meaningful interaction? But the main point was that I don't think those kids would understand map colouring as something beyond map colouring. It's just trivia - you can do it with 4 colours. A huge majority of people of any age doesn't know why that fact is in any way significant.

On the other hand if anyone wants to prove me wrong about kindergarten kids, I'd be glad to hear that.

Re:Unsolved problems with the common core by lkozma on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @09:57AM (#10258553)
I thought that example was quite nice, and it might work with kindergarten kids. It has to be kept easy and not overwhelming, though. I'd do it like this:

First take some simpler map that can be 3-colored and ask the child to 3-color it. Make sure it is always correct (no neighbors have the same color).

Then give a simple map that cannot be 3-colored. Let the child try it for a while, try arguing together or let them try to argue why it is not possible.

Maybe even start with 2-colorable first, and move up slowly to 3 and then to 4.

Mentioning that 4 always works is optional.

Depending on the child's patience, they can even try coming up with the 3-counterexample themselves. It can be a back-and-forth of challenges and solutions between the child and adult.

Re:Unsolved problems with the common core by panic on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @03:01AM (#10257040)
You don't have to call it "graph k-coloring". Especially when so much of math is taught as a solved thing, it's exciting to know there are problems which nobody knows how to solve. You can learn a lot by trying to solve these problems yourself.
Re:Unsolved problems with the common core by VLM on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @10:39AM (#10258845)
>it's exciting to know there are problems which nobody knows how to solve

Not sure this fits in with the systemic cultural goal of authoritarianism and conformity at all costs. I mean we both know its a good goal in an abstract sense, but its directly at odds with what we pay them money to indoctrinate into kids. "Sometimes your leaders can't tell you what to think because they don't know" isn't exactly standard authoritarian conditioning. And "think and imagine" isn't standard conformity-inducing conditioning. Furthermore "here's something important, but we can't graph a metric result on a graph" is inherently insubordinate to existing leadership dogma.

Re:Unsolved problems with the common core by panic on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @08:29PM (#10262642)
Who do you know who pays money explicitly to indoctrinate "authoritarianism and conformity at all costs" into kids? It's true that schools tend to emphasize these values, but I think that's a side-effect of the structure of the system, not an explicit goal. Individual teachers can and often do encourage "thinking and imagining".
Re:Unsolved problems with the common core by lern_too_spel on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @07:00PM (#10262281)
4 colors is the maximum required for planar graphs. It's trivial to construct non-planar graphs that require an arbitrary number of colors.
Re:Unsolved problems with the common core by ucaetano on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @08:10AM (#10258014)
The title is awful, it should be "unsolved mathematical problems associated to common core themes".