News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unit Economics by pbreit on Monday September 21, 2015 @02:53PM (#10254347)
I've gotta think one category he's talking about are the delivery services. I still have not seen a decent articulation of the end-to-end economics. But they can't be terrific.

I know, for example, that Sidecar pays drivers up to $20 for a single delivery and just can't see how this is viable outside of rare exceptions. At least Instacart prices the item being delivered (and I suspect never gives you the yellow ticket price which pretty much every Safeway item gets nowadays).

Re:Unit Economics by exelius on Monday September 21, 2015 @03:18PM (#10254512)
I agree; delivery services will only make sense with autonomous delivery (which I suspect is the long-term plan for all of them - Uber included). But realistically, the R&D required there is crazy if you're trying to be first to market - Amazon and Uber are investing billions in this, and they're the competition.

Once drones or autonomous cars become widespread, this business becomes a commodity and anyone without a legacy business they have to migrate will be at an advantage. So I have no idea why these companies are getting funded other than it's a problem that's simple enough for a really smart university student to tackle.

Re:Unit Economics by _sentient on Monday September 21, 2015 @03:46PM (#10254691)
Uber is profitable in many of its mature markets. This is while charging less than half what you would pay a legacy taxi service, while paying drivers more than they would make at the same.

This is the direct byproduct of strong network effects on both the supply/demand side, paired with operational excellence on their part.

Self driving cars would bring the marginal cost down even further, but they have built a stunningly good business with or without a quantum leap in automation.

The same probably isn't true for many other Uber-for-X companies, particularly those with underwater unit economics.

Re:Unit Economics by Pxtl on Monday September 21, 2015 @04:29PM (#10254930)
Uber's success has nothing to do with their technology and everything to do with the fact that they straight-up ignored the regulations on their industry by claiming to operate in a different one.

The taxi-industry is overregulated and corrupt, so Uber created a "car service" that works exactly like a taxicab.

Re:Unit Economics by cortesoft on Monday September 21, 2015 @04:37PM (#10254969)
It doesn't work just like a taxicab. I can't hail an Uber on the streetcorner by raising my arm.
Re:Unit Economics by jcater on Monday September 21, 2015 @05:23PM (#10255230)
In most places, you don't hail a cab on the streetcorner by raising your hand. In most US cities, you call dispatch.
Re:Unit Economics by exelius on Monday September 21, 2015 @03:52PM (#10254727)
Yeah; Uber had a unique opportunity because the taxi business was stuck in the 20th century and had a bad case of regulatory capture as a result. That said, in Uber's more "mature" markets you're starting to see a lot of the problems that caused the taxi business to regulate in the first place: too many drivers, no way to guarantee steady revenue as a driver, etc.
Re:Unit Economics by hueving on Monday September 21, 2015 @04:18PM (#10254873)
The purpose of the industry isn't to provide steady revenue to drivers. That's a non issue that will be solved by drivers quitting when the price gets too low.
Re:Unit Economics by pbreit on Monday September 21, 2015 @05:03PM (#10255124)
That's not quite true. Regulation frequently aims to smooth out the booms and busts and I would argue that happens in the current taxi industry.
Re:Unit Economics by BurningFrog on Monday September 21, 2015 @06:45PM (#10255608)
Regulation is marketed by nice sounding goals like that, while it is actually motivated by protecting the established players and keeping competition out.
Re:Unit Economics by Daishiman on Monday September 21, 2015 @10:19PM (#10256324)
Yes, all regulations, all the time, and so much evidence to boot!
Re:Unit Economics by pbreit on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @01:02AM (#10256703)
Either way, it smoothes out the booms and busts.
Re:Unit Economics by hueving on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @02:48PM (#10260738)
There isn't really any correlation between smoothness of booms and busts and regulation. Quite frequently regulation causes massive swings because it prevents the market from pricing risk correctly (e.g. The affordable housing act leading to banks not needing to care about mortgage payback risk).
Re:Unit Economics by lifeisstillgood on Monday September 21, 2015 @04:00PM (#10254769)

  Uber is profitable in many of its mature markets. This is 
  while charging less than half what you would pay a legacy  
  taxi service, while paying drivers more than they would 
  make at the same.
What? Seriously? Are you saying that say the cost of a "medallion" is more than twice the cost of all other costs in a taxi service? Can you give any examples?
Re:Unit Economics by nemo44x on Monday September 21, 2015 @04:50PM (#10255052)
The average NYC taxi driver does not own a medallion. A couple years ago they traded hands for $1,000,000.00. Most of them are owned by companies which have many hundreds if not thousands of them.

These companies rent the medallion for 12 hour blocks to drivers and would charge them between $175-250 per block. Before Uber there were many more drivers than medallions and drivers would bid the price of renting the medallion for 12 hours up!

Drivers who worked full time and took a few weeks off would spend around $40,000.00/year on renting the medallion. A cab that was rented for 24 hours/day all year would easily generate $90,000.00/year for the owner of the medallion.

With Uber the companies that own the medallions (and more so those that took massive loans to acquire them) are the ones hurting. The drivers are just fine, if not better. And even taxi drivers I've spoken with like Uber because medallion owners are desperate for drivers now and are charging $100-$150/12 hours. They just want to get the cars out of the garage.

Uber drivers expenses that are different from cab drivers include a car mainly. Something that costs far less than the money they gave medallion owners and something they can write off big parts of on their taxes. And they can use it on their free time.

Re:Unit Economics by thaumasiotes on Monday September 21, 2015 @05:19PM (#10255208)
> Uber drivers expenses that are different from cab drivers include a car mainly. Something that costs far less than the money they gave medallion owners and something they can write off big parts of on their taxes.

Wouldn't renting a medallion be 100% deductible?

Re:Unit Economics by nemo44x on Monday September 21, 2015 @05:26PM (#10255248)
That's a good point. It still costs far less than what they would pay a medallion owner, however. And they get a car.
Re:Unit Economics by lifeisstillgood on Monday September 21, 2015 @07:50PM (#10255872)
But ... https://www.gov.uk/vehicle-licences-private-hire-taxis-londo...

License cost is 154 GBP (200 bucks) annually in London. Not a million. I maybe misunderstanding a lot of the cost issues in taxi services but it seems the medallion cost is a huge racket - but that's hardly a global issue?

Re:Unit Economics by _benedict on Monday September 21, 2015 @09:18PM (#10256134)
That's not a "Black Cab" which would be the equivalent of NYC yellow taxis. A private taxi cannot be hailed on the street, I assume much like yellow taxis. This was once a major advantage, but uber (and equivalent apps) make it almost irrelevant.

Becoming a Black Cab driver is much harder than renting a medallion, though. You have to pass "The Knowledge" which is considered at least as hard as passing a university degree. You have to have an encyclopaedic knowledge of London roads, and generally spend at least a couple of years (often longer) driving around those roads on a scooter so you can demonstrate that knowledge in a series of tests.

I'm not sure if the problem is similar in other major cities, but I expect there is some form of cartel in force in most of the major cities.

However, even if there isn't, there is still a real advantage to profitability from something like uber: if there are enough customers using a passenger exchange, then the likelihood of having passengers near to you is significantly higher. So less of your time is spent in unbillable transit to your next customer. In London there are hundreds of taxi firms; each of them gets some share of the passengers calling them up, so they have to take what they can get. With a central exchange, they get the passengers most suitably located for them from all possible passengers.

Re:Unit Economics by eru on Monday September 21, 2015 @09:10PM (#10256110)
In London they keep supply down with the Knowledge, don't they? So instead of investing money in a medaillon, people invest time.
Re:Unit Economics by DanielDent on Monday September 21, 2015 @04:31PM (#10254937)
In Vancouver (Canada), until recently the market price for a "medallion" was $800,000-$1,400,000. Taxis are often unavailable when you want one. A significant portion of the taxi fare does not got to the driver - it goes to the person they are renting the taxi/medallion from.

Uber briefly entered the market using licensed limousine drivers. They were pushed out because we have a crazy rule that limousine rides can't cost less than $80-90 - the only reason for that rule is so that limousines don't compete with taxis.

It's insane.

Re:Unit Economics by wxs on Monday September 21, 2015 @04:10PM (#10254811)
Wouldn't the statement also be consistent with an increased percentage of car time with a passenger? That is, if all other costs were equal, and occupied time per driver-hour doubled despite per-ride profit halving?
Re:Unit Economics by DMac87 on Monday September 21, 2015 @04:29PM (#10254925)
This doesn't seem that unreasonable - weren't/aren't medallions over $1M in NYC, which is a factor more expensive than labor, fuel, or maintenance of a vehicle...
Re:Unit Economics by exelius on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @01:07PM (#10259977)
Yep, and they were all effectively owned by banks who leased them to cab drivers on a per-shift basis. Your cab driver has to pay ~$150 (I don't know the actual number) per day to drive a cab, so until he makes that $150 back he is losing money. If you had to do this every day, knowing there is a chance you might lose money by going to work, well, you'd be a pretty miserable human being -- just like most NYC taxi drivers.
Re:Unit Economics by ghaff on Monday September 21, 2015 @04:01PM (#10254774)
The logistics industry has actually done a pretty good job of getting deliveries in the 2-4 day range (depending on warehouse locations) across the continental US to the few $$ range whether paid for explicitly or bundled.

But routine same-day delivery even in relatively dense urban areas is still pretty clearly a premium service (and pretty much unavailable if you go 15 miles out of the urban core). Grocery delivery for $10 isn't that interesting to most people if they're in a position to hop in a car or walk 5 blocks. And single items like something from the hardware store don't work at all.

Re:Unit Economics by avip on Monday September 21, 2015 @04:54PM (#10255066)
I'm in Mumbai, and can day-deliver pretty much everything from everywhere. I can order 5 eggs, 1L milk, or a hammer. Not sure how this system works though.
Re:Unit Economics by ghaff on Monday September 21, 2015 @05:03PM (#10255121)
>Not sure how this system works though.

I'm sure the basic answer is very low labor costs. There are lots of personal services available in countries with low labor costs that aren't nearly as affordable in the US.

Re:Unit Economics by ismail on Monday September 21, 2015 @04:51PM (#10255054)
I think there are a few aspects to making delivery service economics work, marginal costs go down the more you can group deliveries and route better in areas. In other words, network effects.

1. Do I need it right this minute ( example pizza)

2. Is it purchased in advance or planned? Like weekly groceries

3. Are you just doing delivery, and that is your only revenue?

4. Will your earn a commission, transaction fee or add a markup? (i.e Instacart)

4. Are you going to follow an uber type model or integrated by hiring staff?

5. Can you group customers orders together and do delivery runs using optimization algorithms (tsp, vrp). Lowering your cost?

Here is an example (Using ZAR values / 10 for approx USD values):

Say you start a diaper delivery business. On average a parents will need it once a month. To make it simple we will assume 1 customer initially, and then scale up to 10. We will compare 2 scenerios.

Here is the example in Google Docs:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1fpdh9BPWJMqWXV-wWRl2...

  Cost of diaper pack: $30

  Avg cost of delivery per KM: $ 0.40

  Distance to Deliver: 20 KM

  Time to deliver & return to Hub: 1 Hour

  Cost Per Hour for Driver (South Africa): $5

  Delivery Fee: $3

  Retail of Diaper with Margin: $35
Scenario 1, No Margin on Diapers, with 1 order

  Total Cost: 30 + (20 * 0.4) + ( 1 * 5) = 43

  Total Revenue: 30 + 3 = 33

  Loss: $10
Scenario 1, No Margin on Diapers, with 10 orders

For simplicity: Driver will drive to furthest point, and each point is 1KM away in direction of the hub.

No change in distance driven. 1 Additional hour as more stops.

  Total Cost: (30 * 10) + (0.4 * 20) + (5 * 2) = 318

  Total Revenue: (30 * 10) + (0.4 * 20) + (10 *3) = 330

  GP: $ 12

  GP %: 3.64
Scenario 2, Margin on Diapers ($5), with 1 order

  Total Cost: 30 + (20 * 0.4) + ( 1 * 5) = 43

  Total Revenue: 35 + 3 = 38

  Loss: $5
Scenario 2, Margin on Diapers, with 10 orders

For simplicity: Driver will drive to furthest point, and each point is 1KM away in direction of the hub.

No change in distance driven. 1 Additional hour as more stops.

  Total Cost: (30 * 10) + (0.4 * 20) + (5 * 2) = 318

  Total Revenue: (35 * 10) + (0.4 * 20) + (10 *3) = 380

  GP: $ 62

  GP %: 16.32 %
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1fpdh9BPWJMqWXV-wWRl2...
Re:Unit Economics by pbreit on Monday September 21, 2015 @05:13PM (#10255176)
That does make some sense but I'm not sure if the assumptions totally work, primarily the "no extra miles" and "only 1 extra hour for 9 more stops".