Another interesting way to speculate is the "under our nose" concept, which is the concept that the existing distribution of stars and galaxies, as well as the recorded background noise, might be the byproduct of alien intervention. Binary star systems are a popular speculative example of "starivore" civilizations that consume entire stars that have been moved into the alien civilization's own star system, and perhaps some combination of multiple stars in a single system are not "naturally" occurring in the absence of alien influence. To an unsuspecting observer, some forms of distant astronomical-scale engineering could be mistakenly interpreted as natural astrophysics that the observers then incorporate into their standard models when refactoring to account for all of the observed data... Usually the simple explanations are correct, but when your models require really insane updates to handle the observed data, perhaps there are other explanations? At the same time though, what recourse would we have if 99% of the visible universe was already astro-engineered?
There is currently no evidence which suggests stars are being moved. We should see either large gravitational tugs or engines such as Shkadov thrusters. The latter should be plainly visible. The former should be easily detected by extrasolar planet detection methods. Unless the tugs are spherical, the light curves of the tugs would definitely pique interest. In any case, moving a star seems a rather extreme and expensive measure. It is probably more effective to consume the star onsite and use the energy locally or send only the energy back.
There seems to be no evidence of stars being consumed, either. Dyson spheres (or swarms) have actually been searched for locally by comparing visible and infrared wavelengths over sections of the sky. None have been found. Intergalactic searches have also been done by looking for galaxies which glow too brightly in the far infrared. No luck.
It is not just a question of a mistaken belief that the artificial is natural. The properties of light are the same here on Earth as they are billions of light years away. Further, for all those galaxies and stars to be engineered in the same way aross billions of light years (with some points being unable to communicate with others since the Big Bang), is all but impossible. Life would have to evolve at effectively the same rate and come up with the same solutions in all those hundreds of billions of galaxies (and yet somehow be different here in the Milky Way). Given the variety of life on Earth and the variety of solutions it has evolved, that seems unlikely.
http://news.discovery.com/space/alien-life-exoplanets/kepler...
http://astronomynow.com/2015/05/24/hubble-observes-one-of-a-...
Edit: to include the third link for Nasty1
Locally, if these events happend long ago, surely they would have been here by now, harvesting our star.
I personally just don't like definitive statements when there's no way for us to know the whole story.
Something similar should exist in the information theory. An encrypted signal can't be "too random", there should be some metric that distinguishes an intelligently designed signal from a random one. With spread spectrum and other tricks they can make it harder but not impossible to detect and separate from pure noise.
What is that metric? I have no idea, just trying to theorize. At least the opposite should be true, that for example the cosmic microwave background can not carry any useful/meaningful information other than just "signatures" of the particles that emitted the signal. So there should be some metric that's different for CMB and any signal that has something else in it.
Edit: I don't think the metric in question is entropy, although someone might convince us that it is. The problem with entropy is that, an object that consists of just a few types of atoms may emit a signal that would look very "orderly". That signal would be the spectrum with a few distinct frequencies in it typically emitted by those atoms.
It should if encryption is good. After all, security proofs for encryption define "secure" as "indistinguishable from random".
The key word here is "computationally". A signal encrypted with a non-OTP symmetric key can be distinguished from noise without the key — unfortunately, for modern key sizes (128, 196, or 256 bits), the cost of doing so is prohibitively expensive for even arbitrarily advanced civilizations, unless (as Brice Schneier put it) they are building computers out of something other than matter that occupy something other than space.
Why not?
Random data is not compressible.
Adding redundant data to random data will make it more compressible - less random.
Not sure what someone could possibly mean by that. Pretty much every celestial body has non-zero jerk. For instance, earth's acceleration is (to pretty good approximation) a constant times the $-e_r/r^2$, and the time derivative of that is definitely not zero.
Actually, if you think about it, the only plausible way you could have something in space with zero jerk and non-zero acceleration would be an interstellar ship maintaining constant acceleration, so the suggested rule is almost exactly wrong.
>a constant times the $-e_r/r^2$, and the time derivative of that is definitely not zero.
I don't see a term there that is time-dependent.
The Drake equation of detecting intelligent life based on their signal emission needs a few extra terms for accounting for energy efficiency or perhaps even deliberate discretion (https://xkcd.com/1377/).
If we did pass through their data laser or whathaveyou, then perhaps it would be unintelligible encrypted information, but that's not something that seems likely to happen (even if things aligned perfectly, other star systems - particularly those with radio emitting civilizations - are probably too noisy to try to transmit through).
The only other alternative I can hazard speculation on is possibly gravity wave signaling? It's a bit of a stretch in my mind since the only real way to do that is to assume certain kinds of unproven particles like gravitinos (these are supposedly able to be interacted with in superconducting materials last time I read about them).
Steganography. Not "background", in the sense that images are generally considered useful, but it is hiding information in a place that a casual onlooker would not think to look.
> Encryption is applied on the data layers not to hide that something is being transmitted, but what is being transmitted.
That's exactly why this encryption would be strong. Initially, no one thinks to look for signals that don't look like signals.
Any sort of steganography tries to achieve something similar. I wouldn't be surprised if something similar would be used in military radio communications.
Encryption is applied on the data layers not to hide that something is being transmitted, but what is being transmitted.
However scientists aren't even trying to detect signals with any sort of data in it, but merely radio emissions that look like they might come from something with an intellect.
If we haven't found anything like that yet, and encryption is supposed to be the reason, then that means that encryption would have to be applied at the most basic protocol layer in such a way that even the physical properties of the emission look like the universe's background radiation. Is there currently human technology that does anything similar to this?