News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by jfoutz on Saturday September 19, 2015 @11:29AM (#10244505)
Have the models really changed that much in 35 years though? This one has all the highlights, radiation balance, 1D and 3D modeling, climate sensitivity, the main feedbacks (water vapor, lapse rate, clouds, ice- and vegetation albedo); solar and volcanic forcing; and ocean heat uptake.

http://www.sciencemag.org/content/213/4511/957

They predict about half a degree C, and that seems to be holding up.

More interesting though, what would be convincing? Computers are fast. To paraphrase the red queen, we accurately predict 6 complex nonlinear systems before breakfast. Do you think there are other hidden effects that humans haven't observed? In what sense is it not settled?

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by guscost on Saturday September 19, 2015 @11:39AM (#10244534)
This may come down to our individual philosophies, but I'm far more interested in what would convince you that a model is wrong. It's a Popperian sentiment, which may be considered quaint these days, but I rarely hear any kind of answer.

Anyway, I don't think we are talking about even close to the same meaning of "complex", but one possible situation that would help convince me is if we had a "control" planet, and an "experimental" planet, with nearly identical climates and biodiversity and so on, and then we raised the CO2 level of the experimental planet, keeping in mind that all kinds of other inputs to the non-linear system should remain the same, like land use, fishing, other industrial activities, etc. If the experimental planet diverged significantly from the control planet, it wouldn't be solid 100% irrefutable proof but it would be far better evidence than anything we have today.

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by jfoutz on Saturday September 19, 2015 @12:09PM (#10244625)
No, i'm with you. Falsification is a huge deal.

As far as "complex" goes, i'm thinking of the old strange attractor. I don't know if it'll rain on sept 19 2016, but i think it's safe to say there will be 3 inches of rain next september. If we refine our understanding and language, there's a nice probability density function for quantity of rain over the month of sept 2016. Not much probability around 0, not much beyond 6, but a big lump right there at 3.

I outright reject the "no model is possible" argument. If nothing else, it's that way because god wills it. Some folks argue weather is related to frequency of gay sex. I'm confident the above paper outperforms that model.

The nice thing about the above model is it is testable. we know historical variation around the prediction. We can make a prediction based on increasing CO2, then increase it, and see how our prediction plays out. (edit and we did, and the model was pretty good, but earth actually got warmer faster than the paper predicted http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2012/04/evalua...)

So, anyway, weather works "somehow" and we can make forecasts. Although it's never been tested, i'm pretty sure Pat Robertson is wrong and it's not gay sex driven.

So, i still dont' get why it's not settled. The best models we have are refinements of the above paper. Is there some other model that gives better answerers?

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by guscost on Saturday September 19, 2015 @12:38PM (#10244732)
I'll agree that your favorite model is lot more likely to work than the "because gay sex" model, because your favorite model presumably has causal relationships based on measurable reality.

And I like the idea that atmospheric composition could be a strange attractor in the climate system.

But then you'd have to throw the simple forcing model for CO2 out the window, and come up with a hypothesis for why there is a strange attractor somehow causing CO2 and temperature to exhibit a linear relationship. Wouldn't your favorite model have to be rewritten at that point?

And then you'd need an explanation for how the water vapor feedback forcing (a critical part of most alarmist models) fits into those dynamics. And why a similar albedo forcing or plant cover forcing or fracking-earthquake forcing or Chinese economic forcing does not. I don't think you will find it simple to describe at anything but the most abstract level. But it is an interesting idea.

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by jfoutz on Saturday September 19, 2015 @01:20PM (#10244886)
I think we hit the max depth, so i'm replying here.

Yes, i enjoy civil rational discussions (well, i try to be rational) on HN. there's a bunch of smart people and it's fun.

Anyway, i think i get your point, allow me to phrase it this way "they may be getting the right answers, but they aren't getting the answers for the right reasons"

My handwavy counter argument is, Aristotle said "continuous motion requires continuous application of force" and he was wrong. But in day to day life, if you need to move the cart, you gotta keep pushing on it. He wasn't dead wrong, he did capture some essence the truth. Newton came along and got more of it. Einstein got even more.

Allow me to put a few more words in your mouth. I think you weakly agree with the climate scientists, not the crazy militants, but the grad students sitting in a tiny office doing math. You don't think they're dead wrong, they just don't have enough of the truth to be useful, newton hasn't come along yet and shown us how it all fits together.

Ok, i gotta go get some stuff done, but it was indeed thoughtful and fun.

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by guscost on Saturday September 19, 2015 @02:15PM (#10245064)
Yep, that sounds fairly reasonable. I'm just an amateur philosopher of science so I don't really have my own theories to add here, but I do find a lot of what's out there interesting. I don't like seeing politicians run directly towards their favorite conclusions with whatever half-formed material they can find, because it actively subverts the interesting parts (and sure, I don't agree with the politics in this case).
Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by jfoutz on Saturday September 19, 2015 @12:43PM (#10244748)
Point me at the paper that outperforms that model. I'll do my best to read and understand it.
Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by guscost on Saturday September 19, 2015 @12:56PM (#10244802)
This is an irrelevant tangent, but I liked the previous dialogue.
Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by giaour on Saturday September 19, 2015 @01:26PM (#10244906)
He's asking you, "what causes you to see your belief as more valid, other than nihilism?" I wouldn't call that an irrelevant tangent.
Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by drewrv on Saturday September 19, 2015 @12:04PM (#10244612)
>one possible situation that would help convince me is if we had a "control" planet

So on this one issue it's impossible for you to be convinced.

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by guscost on Saturday September 19, 2015 @12:16PM (#10244655)
Not at all, there could be plenty of other evidence, I just can't imagine what it would be. Other than some kind of control planet, or maybe a complete overturning of nonlinear dynamics and/or chaos theory maybe.

Of course, if the ocean was engulfing whole communities faster than people could run uphill, or people were choking on CO2, I'd probably be a whole lot less rational about it and say "let's throw things at the wall to see what sticks."

But so far, and after reading what I figure are among the strongest arguments out there, it still looks like your typical doomsday story dressed up as science.

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by nitrogen on Saturday September 19, 2015 @12:29PM (#10244703)
Okay, ignore warming if you like. We still need to stop producing so much CO2 because it's acidifying the oceans and destroying ecosystems we depend on for food.
Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by jberryman on Saturday September 19, 2015 @02:44PM (#10245160)
> I'd probably be a whole lot less rational...

I think you imagine that you are being very rational, because you've studied some climate science and believe you're intelligent enough to form your own judgement, but you're wrong. It's extremely irrational to dismiss the consensus opinion of climate science researchers based on your own (epistomologically limited, non-professional-climate-scientist) assessment of their research.

> it still looks like your typical doomsday story dressed up as science.

And say the likelihood of this doomsday scenario being correct is 10% by your assessment: do you think a rational risk analysis would conclude that we should do nothing and go about business as usual? Do you also enjoy playing russian roulette when your not skimming climate science articles?

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by lotharbot on Saturday September 19, 2015 @01:57PM (#10245005)
the thing about nonlinear dynamics/chaos is that it still allows for some degree of control and prediction -- not in the sense of being able to predict one specific trajectory, but in the sense of being able to make statistical predictions about likely regions for the trajectory to pass through, and even to be able to apply small controls to change a trajectory drastically and potentially keep it out of entire regions.

See, for example, http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1046/j.1461-0248.2001.... (yet another tribolium paper. The favorite insect of nonlinear dynamics and chaos books everywhere.)

I don't think we need to overturn anything mathematically to be able to talk sensibly about climate models, predictions, complex forcing mechanisms, and control. We just have to stop putting the cart before the horse (or the shady politician before the scientist) and look at what can be done to stabilize the ecosystem -- not necessarily worrying about catastrophic predictions, but simply looking at some of the measurable negative effects (like acidifying oceans, brought up in a sibling comment) and determining how to control the system in order to slow or even reverse those effects.