News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by _yosefk on Saturday September 19, 2015 @06:01AM (#10243841)
It's nice that they used examples of problems denied by supporters of more than a single political party. I think we all do that.

(Go programmers are less likely to acknowledge problems solved by generics as real, C++ programmers are less likely to acknowledge problems solved by garbage collection and boundary checking as real, Python programmers are less likely to acknowledge problems solved by static typing as real, same for Haskell programmers & lazy evaluation, etc. This is "political" in the sense, for instance, that a more popular language is tremendously more useful, so you want a language you've invested into to be popular even if it fails badly at solving a real problem; there are real benefits to denying it being a real problem if others believe it isn't real and that belief makes the language more popular.)

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by asgard1024 on Saturday September 19, 2015 @06:48AM (#10243902)
> It's nice that they used examples of problems denied by supporters of more than a single political party. I think we all do that.

I disagree, the two examples (climate change and gun control) aren't that different. Both are issues of personal freedom.

I actually wish they would show some blind spots of collectivist liberal anarchists (people like Chomsky), who I feel very close political sympathies to. I am (obviously) not aware of these blind spots.

I am not sure I entirely buy the idea of "everybody has blindspots" (EHB). It seems to me that liberal democracy, the idea that everybody is entitled to their moral opinion and should have the same influence over what we consider moral, is pretty much an attempt to get rid of any blindspots. The argument EHB is akin to saying "atheists are also believers".

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by nabla9 on Saturday September 19, 2015 @07:31AM (#10243987)
>I actually wish they would show some blind spots of collectivist liberal anarchists

The obvious blind spot is the problem caused by politicization of everyday life.

Faceless authority where your value is determined by market forces and laws that come far above you may feel problematic because it's faceless and impersonal. Impersonality is also benefit. When you do your job and go home, you don't have to suck up for the boss in free time and he don't care what your political views are.

In small democratic organization you have a face. The good thing is that you have a voice and can participate more. The bad thing is that you have a face. Your political opinions and your personal relationships and personality is part of the game. Your professional life is in the hands of your peers and the cliques that organically form.

See also: http://www.jofreeman.com/joreen/tyranny.htm

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by asgard1024 on Saturday September 19, 2015 @11:41AM (#10244539)
This is an interesting point. However, I am not convinced that life under "market forces" is less political than elsewhere. I would like to see some evidence.

I also think the point (and large success) of democracy is that it distributes power equally, so we simply stop wasting time on fighting for it and get the stuff done. Especially in direct democracy. So I think what you are saying only applies to "naive" (maybe even strawman) anarchism, where there are no rules, not the democratic one (that I think Chomsky admires).

> you don't have to suck up for the boss in free time and he don't care what your political views are

I am actually not sure this is true in small enterprises. I haven't worked for one, but I know one can get easily fired for voicing sympathies with unions, for instance.

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by ArkyBeagle on Saturday September 19, 2015 @11:42AM (#10244544)
What Chomsky does is impeccable scholarship, but then he inevitably seems (to me!) to overreach on the conclusions. I don't know if it's blind spots or not.

As an example, I do not hold that any colonialist explanation for US involvement in Vietnam is necessary. There's an awful lot of ... circumstantial evidence to suggest that, but I don't know for a fact that anyone in the US explicitly wanted to do it for that reason - it's much more likely that simple anticommunism suffices.

After all, weren't the Chinese, in very complex ways, just wanting to "colonize" Vietnam through Ho Chi Minh?

But behind that is the message that power corrupts, and on that point, Chomsky is spot on. But I happen to think it's more about the powerful being constrained by circumstance and resources than by them simply being arbitrary. We have ample evidence of this from LBJ's White House tapes.

But that is perhaps my bias and blind spot, and maybe he's right.

Climate change is different in that cheap energy props up people who struggle economically in the US. So that's why I don't like carbon taxes as well as a solution.

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by speccy_geek on Saturday September 19, 2015 @10:44AM (#10244388)
A common liberal blind spot is the genetic basis of intelligence and other aptitudes, and the extent to which that determines life outcomes.
Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by asgard1024 on Saturday September 19, 2015 @11:48AM (#10244556)
I consider myself liberal yet I don't agree with it, though you're right, there are many elitist liberals around. I think they are easily spotted by their opposition to direct democracy.

And I actually think we should always assume "nurture". My reasoning is when you assume "nature", that's a dead end. This is a similar argument to whether the world is knowable - assuming it is will get you further.

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by nitrogen on Saturday September 19, 2015 @12:42PM (#10244744)
How is that a dead end? I have greater confidence in humanity's ability to find a genetic therapy to boost intelligence than its ability to compensate for bad parenting and culture.
Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by asgard1024 on Saturday September 19, 2015 @03:06PM (#10245236)
Assuming the current level of technology of course - I don't think there is anyone who successfully improved their own intelligence with biotechnology. Once there is such therapy, it simply becomes "nurture". But I am not sure that even matters, people are creative and they will find a way to blame unsuccessful people or nations for systemic failures.

Genetic therapy as our future? It's likely you will get choices like "you can have 1 more IQ point, bigger toenails and 10% higher risk of cardiovascular disease after 50".

On the other hand, you can do this today, and pick an intelligent partner to have kids with. And people do and we have empirical evidence of growing IQ (but actually it is explained by nurture) - regardless some still talk about how Idiocracy is our future.

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by _yosefk on Saturday September 19, 2015 @07:56AM (#10244045)
If a "blind spot" is understood literally then to have no blind spots would require to see, well, everything there is to see at the same time, which is sorta impossible. I think it's pretty obvious that our ability to think - to take facts into account and work out their consequences - is necessarily very much limited by a finite input bandwidth, a finite storage capacity and a finite processing capacity, and so any finite brain will have mental blind spots. To believe otherwise is to be a great believer indeed, IMO...
Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by panic on Saturday September 19, 2015 @07:03AM (#10243932)
Do you think something like the iPhone could have been produced under a collectivist economic regime?
Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by asgard1024 on Saturday September 19, 2015 @07:41AM (#10244011)
Generally, yes!

But it really depends on what you mean by "collectivist". Could iPhone be produced by IBM, a huge corporation with top-down command and control? It's about as likely, I would say.

I work at medium American corporation and it's not really that different from what was called "socialist" enterprise here in Czech Republic. It is certainly more efficient, but sometimes pathologically - good ideas get killed all the time. And there is not really that much less stupidity to go around.

And socialism here (I take it from your question that's what you imagine as "collectivist") certainly wasn't ideal system for liberal left, who would probably prefer some form of worker cooperatives or something like that.

Perhaps I should emphasize what I mean by "collectivist" in my previous comment. I actually refer to empathy (or less selfishness) rather than form of ownership. What I mean is understanding that other side can have a different opinion and willingness to compromise (e.g. your personal freedom) with the needs/feelings of others. It doesn't mean you have to entirely ditch the free market, for instance.

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by bobcostas55 on Saturday September 19, 2015 @08:23AM (#10244082)
I think the parent meant it in a more general sense. Apple doesn't single-handedly produce the iPhone, it takes the coordination of millions of people, most of whom have no contact with Apple whatsoever: those who design oil drilling equipment, those who build it, those who use oil drilling equipment, those who then extract the oil, transport it, refine it, transport it, turn it into plastic bits for the iphone, transport them, put everything together, transport it. And there's a chain like that for every thing in the phone (for some items, such as CPUs the chain is far more complex). There is no top-down command and control, and I doubt it's possible. The only reason coordination on such a massive scale works is because of the price mechanism.
Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by asgard1024 on Saturday September 19, 2015 @10:59AM (#10244429)
I don't think the coordination is the problem, frankly, it seems like an ideological red herring (specifically, I don't think it really matters whether you have oligopolistic or free market prices). "Socialist" countries had a kind of "internal market", although it tended to be very regulated. In particular, price mechanism was present, so the information was available to decision makers. I think there were two other causes:

1. The power structure, on the state level and "business" level, not accountable enough to the people it should serve - no democracy, no consumer choice. The latter was somewhat reduced in the businesses that exported (usually to the third world).

2. Tendency of the regulators to "cut down" the expenses and designating single company to produce certain thing as a means to save resources. This caused huge delays in production as the individual delays accumulated, and in fact caused waste. (I think it's actually redundancy, not efficiency per se, of free markets that is one of the causes of their resulting efficiency.)

Democracy and being able to start independent business (which is not the same as free market or capitalism!) seem to be the two main advantages of the West compared to the East. But you can also see that both problems plague large enterprises in the West, yet despite that they are workhorses of the economy. You can also see that many very successful countries have oligopolies, state-owned enterprises, strong unions, and lots of regulation in general.

I just decided to recheck the thread because I thought that parent asked something yet different, namely, how could innovation happen in collectivist system (whatever that is). I assure you there was plenty of innovation going on in the "socialist" countries; the problem was getting things approved, tested, and produced by the people who decided about resources. Similar challenges are faced by innovators at the bottom in a large corporation.

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by nn3 on Saturday September 19, 2015 @08:53AM (#10244138)
The Soviet Union built some fairly complex machines too, for example buran the Russian space shuttle, nuclear power plants, large airplanes, submarines etc. I don't think these are significantly less complex than an iPhone. Likely more. Now you could argue they did it less frequently or less efficient and not really benefitting the average consumer in many cases. And that would be true. But there is no denying that a top down economy did those things.
Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by guard-of-terra on Saturday September 19, 2015 @10:18AM (#10244337)
Soviet Union routinely failed to sell its nuclear plants, airliners and less complex stuff.

Soviet Union was able to produce something that worked, but it was all below price-quality curve. I.e. you could buy same quality product from Western corporations for less money; or you could buy better quality product for same money. Western corporations also had better selection.

So only buyers were in communist bloc, and what USSR end up exporting is oil and gas.

And that'll happen nine times out of ten, since socialist economies are not optimal.

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by danharaj on Saturday September 19, 2015 @10:57AM (#10244418)
I don't know why we're calling the USSR socialist; is it because they said they were socialist? There are plenty of dictatorial regimes that call themselves democratic republics, too. The USSR was structured like one massive corporation: Everything was owned by the government and the government bureaucracy functioned much like a corporate bureaucracy.

Libertarian socialists sometimes call states like the USSR state capitalist, because economic activity is still dictated by a top-down hierarchy allocating capital and exploiting workers.

Optimal is not the word you want to use, by the way. Not even free markets are optimal, that's why economists talk about 'market failures'.

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by asgard1024 on Saturday September 19, 2015 @11:31AM (#10244512)
I agree with you, though I used the Czech Republic as an example because that's how it is commonly (yet wrongly) understood by the other side. It can be seen as collectivist in some ways, but in some it is much less. And I think the detailed comparison actually shows that the problem lies elsewhere (as you correctly state - concentration of power).
Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by guard-of-terra on Saturday September 19, 2015 @11:09AM (#10244451)
The USSR was not structured like one massive corporation. Corporation tends to seek profit; while USSR sought survival. Was bad at it, too: built millions of tanks and other military hardware that rusted without any battle, lost the cold war and tanked.
Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by danharaj on Saturday September 19, 2015 @11:50AM (#10244568)
You're talking about purpose, not structure. I'll agree, the USSR's purpose was not profit, because profit does not make sense if you're trying to own everything. The USSR's goals were growth and, as a logical consequence of growth, not shrinking, i.e. survival. It failed, yes. The larger a hierarchy and its concentration of resources, leadership, and power at the pinnacle, the worse it performs. This occurs with corporations in a capitalist system as well, but since it is not a defining feature of such corporations that they must own everything, their existence is more flexible. They can merge, split, be acquired, get sold off, get refinanced, etc. In this way, the capitalists (viz. people who make their living off of property ownership) can preserve their ownership even if their power structures fail.

So the key difference between the USSR and the Liberal states in opposition to it is the notion of property. Under the USSR, all property is state property and under the Liberal states, property is the bourgeois notion of property.

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by jameshart on Saturday September 19, 2015 @02:48PM (#10245172)
My iPhone was made in China. Where was yours made?
Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by Malician on Saturday September 19, 2015 @04:35PM (#10245476)
It was not designed in China, as a unified part. In fact, even the important components were not designed or manufactured in China. Even the CPU was manufactured in Taiwan or Korea depending on the phone version.

http://www.smics.com/eng/index.php The state semiconductor corp is still on 40nm, which the Taiwanese TSMC hit seven years ago.

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by pekk on Saturday September 19, 2015 @11:22AM (#10244489)
Rather than being examples of solution aversion, these are examples of trade-offs. Garbage collection solves some problems, but causes others, which is why not all software uses it. Static typing might help with some things, but causes other problems, which is why dynamic typing exists.

Though you are trying to make a point about communities like Go, C++, Python, and Haskell, you yourself are showing certain prejudices as far as language features that are not objectively justifiable, and it's not really any different.

Re:Denying Problems When We Don’t Like the Solutions by nostrademons on Saturday September 19, 2015 @12:21PM (#10244671)
The causation may work the other way. Go programmers may be Go programmers because problems caused by generics aren't common for them. Python programmers might be using Python because they're working in a domain where static typing causes more problems than it solves.

Similarly, many people may choose their political party because the issues the party ignores just aren't that important to them.

That's pretty much what making a values trade-off is: accepting some problems as normal and unfixable because the fix, in your eyes, isn't worth the trouble it causes.