Re:What we break when we fix ad blocking
by bradleyjg on Friday September 18, 2015 @11:18PM
(#10243156)
There were options. You could go to concerts, you could listen to the radio. You could go to free concerts in the park. What you couldn't do was listen to the latest Britney album when and wherever you wanted without going and buying the CD or unethically downloading it off of Napster.
You could tell yourself that you were perfectly justified in doing so. In fact it was Britney's fault for not coming up with easy way for you to pay her and get 128mbit mp3s from your pajamas in your room. But I didn't buy it then, and I don't buy it now.
Re:What we break when we fix ad blocking
by emp_zealoth on Saturday September 19, 2015 @07:28AM
(#10243979)
But now there is Spotify, and it's getting more money than I'd spend on buying CD's
I haven't downloaded any music in years
Re:What we break when we fix ad blocking
by ianlevesque on Saturday September 19, 2015 @04:33AM
(#10243705)
Yeah I mean, iTunes Music Store never came into existence to fill the demand. You must be right.
Re:What we break when we fix ad blocking
by loco5niner on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @11:22AM
(#10259154)
You're getting shot down here. Perhaps if you found an argument NOT based on the music model...
What you're saying here is that, if you don't like advertising, your only ethical option is to never use the Web again. (Well, I suppose I can read the comments on Hacker News. None of the articles, though.) That is not reasonable. I have actually gone out of my way to configure my adblocker to un-block as many inoffensive ad providers as possible, because I want to support the sites I use, but when those sites are knowingly degrading not just my browsing experience but the functioning of my computer, measures need to be taken.
> I'm reminded of the debates that raged on the internet when Napster was around. All the people downloading music strenuously claimed that the industry model was broken and they should come up with a new one. Well, if that's what they thought why weren't they out there patronizing artists using a new model?
Because there weren't any new models yet. Which is why the downloaders wanted people to come up with one.