Re:What we break when we fix ad blocking
by toothbrush on Friday September 18, 2015 @04:46PM
(#10241966)
I guess that you're right, mostly. Initiatives to pass city laws against advertising do exist, though [1]. I don't live in Grenoble so i cannot comment on how this plays out in practice, but i wish all cities would do that.
1. http://www.euronews.com/2014/11/26/grenoble-europe-s-first-a...
Re:What we break when we fix ad blocking
by toomuchtodo on Friday September 18, 2015 @10:54PM
(#10243118)
Billboards are illegal in Vermont, Alaska, Hawaii, and Maine.
Re:What we break when we fix ad blocking
by jonhohle on Saturday September 19, 2015 @08:23AM
(#10244081)
I wondered how they got around the first amendment - here's more info on that (not specific to those states) - http://www.firstamendmentcenter.org/billboards
Re:What we break when we fix ad blocking
by copsarebastards on Saturday September 19, 2015 @12:21PM
(#10244674)
Did you read the page you linked?
The supreme court ruled that billboard bans based on location (for city and land planning purposes) would be appropriate, but billboard bans which determined which kinds of content were appropriate for public discourse were unconstitutional. A blanket ban across the state is constitutional, but a ban which targets certain kinds of content is not.
Such bans are completely possible and within the rights of a local jurisdiction - they're just extremely rare and not something society generally seems to care about. In actuality, branding and advertising is engrained in our culture. I hear friends talk about their favorite ads all the time - instead of the TV show the ads interrupted. I know a very large number of people who watch the Superbowl "just for the ads". I can't convince anyone who visits me in NYC to skip Times Square, because they really want to see that pit of blinking ads for themselves. Many moviegoers love how the theater wastes 15 minutes of their time playing previews (i.e. ads). I could go on and on with my biased examples :)
My point is that we are a consumerist society; anyone who has worked in advertising lives off of this fact and knows it's true. The real problem is internet advertisers took it way too far.