I hope I'm not a total tin foil hatter by looking askew at this trend, but being married to a neurologist and the son of a behaviorist, I'm VERY aware of how little we understand what we're doing when we muck around up there.
I don't see why that couldn't make perfect sense, though: someone can be neurochemically imbalanced along multiple axes, but one imbalance can mask the other. For example, if I have ADHD (for real) and depression, then that'll look like I just have depression. If I'm not getting out of bed, you're not going to observe me being very impulsive or notice when I fail to desire to practice things.
But now, if I take an anti-depressant and the depression goes away enough for me to get out of bed, it looks to the study like "in some people, a side-effect of treatment X for depression is [the symptoms of ADHD]." What it really was is that I had a comorbidity.
When you add the brain into the equation, it removes all of the (comparatively flawless) understanding we have of the system the libraries are running within, and then when you add benzos, one of your libraries is now an enraged bobcat.
In a perfect world, I'd agree with your statements. I do not think we have an effective enough understanding of either the compounds we're using, or the systems we're impacting, to be as laissez faire with cocktails as we often are.
I've heard this is used as a form of torture in some countries. Being strapped down and injected with a medication that induces akathisia would make the most hardened individual talk.
Akathisia is a side effect of antidepressants that causes an intense inner restlessness and inability to sit still. This can cause agonizing pain and terrible anxiety, and people can resort to extreme behaviors to relieve their symptoms, often becoming violent.
This has been known for a while now. If you look at the references on the Wikipedia page for akathisia, you find one paper linking antidepressant-induced akathisia to violence from 2006:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1564177/
Quoting from that paper on akathisia:
“Increased tenseness, restlessness, insomnia and a feeling of being very uncomfortable”.
“On the first day of treatment he reacted with marked anxiety and weepiness, on the second day felt so terrible with such marked panic at night that the medication was cancelled”.
“The first few doses frequently made them anxious and apprehensive. They reported increased feelings of strangeness, verbalised by statements such as ‘I don't feel myself’ or ‘I'm afraid of some of the unusual impulses I have'’.
"Events such as these in clinical trials of antidepressants have commonly been coded under headings such as agitation, emotional lability, and hyperkinesis (overactivity), and only rarely to akathisia."
The good thing is that you can treat akathisia with common medicines already used to treat anxiety, such as benzodiazepines. The bad thing is that since information on side effects has been suppressed, patients are not likely to know what is happening to them and how to treat it, won't get the help they need, and run the risk of hurting themselves or others.