"Corrugated is the single most recycled packaging material: 91 percent of corrugated produced in 2012 was recovered for recycling, and almost all of that material was recycled into new products." - http://www.corrugated.org/ViewPage.aspx?ContentID=38
Non-recycled aluminum is horrible but recycled is a nearly perfect resource. Glass is about as good as it gets.
That mug in the example might require horrible amounts of highly toxic inputs to be created and not be able to reclaim any of those input debts through recycling. By looking at the totality of the production, you come to realize that durable good is actually a really bad idea (all assumptions here in this specific instance are totally pulled out of my butt... do not take as a claim to accuracy... thanks)
For example, ~18 uses of a ceramic cup = 1 'recyclable' paper cup. https://www.quora.com/Which-one-is-a-more-environment-friend...