I can't imagine wanting to give out my bank details to allow direct debit of my account to every online retailer I do business with. Weird.
US consumer protection laws treat credit and debit cards differently. They favor credit cards. The gap between the two is up to the goodwill of your bank.
I prefer to rely on law than goodwill. I have never had a problem with getting a refund on a credit card charge I claimed was fraud.
I have no idea why people choose to use a debit card over a credit card here.
One reason it's so hard to unseat credit cards in the US is because most of the advantages of the alternatives are on the sellers side. The consumer doesn't seen any benefit from switching to Apple Pay or whatever. Most merchant agreements don't even let stores charge less for using non-credit card type payments (although some stores do anyway).
As a US citizen I use my credit cards constantly. It's an instant 1% discount on everything I buy (thanks to the cash back), and its fast and easy. I pay it off every month to avoid paying interest. There's basically no downside to me.
The story would be different if retailers were allowed to directly pass on the service fees however. I would definitely think twice if every time I used it I got surcharged $0.50.
OTOH, my Chase experience was not nearly as smooth.
Don't know about iDEAL, but I think that wouldn't work.
The thing: If you don't implement all of this yourself, you don't need to worry about the details. There are services that happily do this for you.
That's the reason they recommended to use a payment gateway that implements all those local payment solutions. For example, in Germany you loose a lot of customers if you don't offer direct debit (ELV) as many don't own a credit card (and don't want to).
> you typically don't have the same chargeback rights when using a banking service like iDEAL
This heavily depends on the service. For example, the upcoming German Paydirekt will offer better chargeback service than most German credit cards (where you typically don't enjoy the US-style "anything is reversible" type of protection).