News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Is Officially a Commodity, According to U.S. Regu... by kbenson on Thursday September 17, 2015 @10:18PM (#10237201)
No, I think the point is that her method of receiving payment is functionally no different than if they drop shipped gold bullion to her. She must convert it into a usable currency in most cases.
Re:Bitcoin Is Officially a Commodity, According to U.S. Regu... by xorcist on Friday September 18, 2015 @02:37AM (#10237777)
If that's your mindset, then look at it like this: Bitcoin is a technology for shipping gold buillion equivalents to any remote location in the world in under the hour, for the price of a tenth of a cent. Pretty nifty, is it not?
Re:Bitcoin Is Officially a Commodity, According to U.S. Regu... by kbenson on Friday September 18, 2015 @03:06AM (#10237863)
Mindset? I was simply providing a different, I think more accurate, interpretation of the anecdote presented upthread. The person was paid in bitcoin, but in this specific case, because of the circumstances, I think it's no different than if they were paid in some other easily fungible commodity, such as gold. I interpreted the usefulness in getting paid in bitcoin not that the worker now had an easily used currency, but that the worker now had a commodity that could be exchanged for a local currency to actually buy most things needed, and it was cheaper than dealing with the local currency exchange fees.

Yes, it also points to the utility of bitcoin, but this specific example also points to it's use as a commodity, IMO. As it gains in popularity, I think it will gain more utility as a currency, but until then it's a currency of limited use (limited in that there are limited venues that accept it) except as a commodity.

Re:Bitcoin Is Officially a Commodity, According to U.S. Regu... by lmm on Friday September 18, 2015 @02:41AM (#10237792)
Nifty? Sure. Deserving different tax treatment from gold bullion? Nope.
Re:Bitcoin Is Officially a Commodity, According to U.S. Regu... by wstrange on Thursday September 17, 2015 @10:44PM (#10237255)
Gold bullion is rather expensive to ship and insure.

Bitcoin seems quite promising for foreign currency transactions.

Re:Bitcoin Is Officially a Commodity, According to U.S. Regu... by TheCoelacanth on Friday September 18, 2015 @10:39AM (#10239436)
Yes, so it's an unprecedentedly easy to transport commodity, but that doesn't mean it's not a commodity.
Re:Bitcoin Is Officially a Commodity, According to U.S. Regu... by s73v3r on Thursday September 17, 2015 @11:04PM (#10237295)
Only if someone in the destination currency is willing to trade that currency for Bitcoin.
Re:Bitcoin Is Officially a Commodity, According to U.S. Regu... by dasil003 on Friday September 18, 2015 @02:10AM (#10237718)
Isn't that true for all (or at least most major) currencies at the moment?
Re:Bitcoin Is Officially a Commodity, According to U.S. Regu... by VMG on Friday September 18, 2015 @04:48AM (#10238134)
It's certainly easier to sell Bitcoin locally than gold bullion.
Re:Bitcoin Is Officially a Commodity, According to U.S. Regu... by notahacker on Friday September 18, 2015 @11:01AM (#10239572)
I'm not convinced that's true in very many countries.
Re:Bitcoin Is Officially a Commodity, According to U.S. Regu... by ryanlol on Saturday September 19, 2015 @01:08PM (#10244844)
You probably won't be getting too good prices for gold in such countries either.
Re:Bitcoin Is Officially a Commodity, According to U.S. Regu... by dpc_pw on Friday September 18, 2015 @08:25PM (#10242813)
So when I was getting paid in dollars, and converted it to my local currency right away, I was proving that USD is a commodity? I could not get anything with USD, so it is not a currency? Interesting.

What people miss is that commodity and currency are not exclusive. And the difference between them does not really matter all that much.

Re:Bitcoin Is Officially a Commodity, According to U.S. Regu... by kbenson on Saturday September 19, 2015 @01:20AM (#10243380)
> So when I was getting paid in dollars, and converted it to my local currency right away, I was proving that USD is a commodity?

Yes. It is a commodity. People trade in it every day.

> I could not get anything with USD, so it is not a currency?

For your use at that location, apparently not.

> What people miss is that commodity and currency are not exclusive.

Yes, and I said as much in a separate reply.

> And the difference between them does not really matter all that much.

Except for when they are classified as one and not the other and taxed differently.