News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:States with the highest taxes also rank as the unhappiest? by Gorm-Casper on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @05:12PM (#1023343)
To make a general statement like that based on a study purely on USA, seems wrong.

I used to live in Denmark where they (according studies I won't bother digging up now) have both the happiest people on the planet AND pay the highest percentage in tax.

Re:States with the highest taxes also rank as the unhappiest? by CWuestefeld on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @05:24PM (#1023368)
To make a general statement like that based on a study purely on USA, seems wrong.

On the contrary. The author seems to be trying only to apply her conclusions to America, so it would be appropriate.

Also, bringing other variables into the regression (societal factors, etc.) would just muddy the waters. If we've got a sample that excludes some variables altogether, it would make sense to use it (with the caveat that we can't know what effect those other dimensions might have).

Re:States with the highest taxes also rank as the unhappiest? by ajross on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @06:02PM (#1023434)
Uh, what? Ignoring evidence is never correct. The burden goes the other way around -- you need to prove the absence of uncorrected correlations if you want to do a good science. You can't just limit your study to a cherry-picked set and announce that "you're only trying to apply your conclusions to the studied subjects".
Re:States with the highest taxes also rank as the unhappiest? by drp on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @05:21PM (#1023357)
States in this case is referring to US states, so I wouldn't say the statement is general.