News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lower Cost S3 Storage Option and Glacier Price Reduction by devit on Thursday September 17, 2015 @04:43AM (#10232252)
Aren't these services still wildly overpriced?

At $0.0125/GB/month, that means it costs $75 for 6TB per month.

But a 6TB hard drive costs less than $300, which means that assuming the data is stored on 3 hard drives for redundancy, they break even in less than a year.

However, hard drives seems to last at least 3-5 years on average, so this service seems to be priced at least 3-5 times as much as it costs to Amazon.

And there is even a $0.01/GB charge for retrieval on top.

There are other costs, but they should be relatively small at scale.

Am I missing something? If not, why doesn't anybody compete with Amazon and provide more reasonable pricing?

Re:Lower Cost S3 Storage Option and Glacier Price Reduction by acveilleux on Thursday September 17, 2015 @10:01AM (#10233353)
You'd need 3 pairs of 6TB hard disks in 3 data centers to match the reliability that S3 provides.

So at least 6 HDDs, 1800$ of H/W and the monthly hosting costs for the 3 DCs and presumably 3 server chassis... Plus software to keep them in sync and you need to deal with the inevitable failures that will happen eventually.

Amazon guarantees 11 9's worth of durability (99.999999999%).

Backblaze sees between 2.41% and 7.77% annual failure rate on 6TB HDDs (source: https://www.backblaze.com/blog/best-hard-drive/) and they're the only ones publishing numbers like these over sensible number of HDDs.

Re:Lower Cost S3 Storage Option and Glacier Price Reduction by discodave on Thursday September 17, 2015 @05:01AM (#10232297)
Go look up one of James Hamilton's talks, he breaks down the cost of running datacenters/cloud. 'Servers' are ~50% of the cost, hard drives are of course less than 100% of server costs.

So you need to at least double the cost of the hard drive. Tripling the cost of hard drives might be a good assumption for S3/Glacier because you could assume they are building servers where hard drives make up 2/3 the cost of the server.

Re:Lower Cost S3 Storage Option and Glacier Price Reduction by threatofrain on Thursday September 17, 2015 @05:15AM (#10232335)
Amazon offers features of reliability which you normally wouldn't attempt to tackle yourself, such as geographically diverse storage and really high reliability rates. You don't have to worry about what technology they use behind the scenes.

If you set up your own system, you have to manage all the technology and risk management strategies. Then you can see if you can do it cheaper than Amazon.

Re:Lower Cost S3 Storage Option and Glacier Price Reduction by zzleeper on Thursday September 17, 2015 @04:54AM (#10232276)
My guess is off site backup is expensive. Also add the electricity costs, CPU etc, engineers, rent, etc.

I That probably takes the margin from 80% of price to maybe 40%, in line with most retailers and whatnot

Re:Lower Cost S3 Storage Option and Glacier Price Reduction by ju-st on Thursday September 17, 2015 @06:19AM (#10232493)
Glacier isn't even using hard drives, so their per TB costs should be way lower (raw storage and infrastructure).
Re:Lower Cost S3 Storage Option and Glacier Price Reduction by kalleboo on Thursday September 17, 2015 @07:10AM (#10232638)
> Glacier isn't even using hard drives

That's still speculation right? Some have theorized they use offline harddisks

Re:Lower Cost S3 Storage Option and Glacier Price Reduction by acveilleux on Thursday September 17, 2015 @10:02AM (#10233357)
I would expect offline HDDs as well, possibly combined with tapes for secondary copies to meet durability requirements.
Re:Lower Cost S3 Storage Option and Glacier Price Reduction by imaginenore on Thursday September 17, 2015 @03:06PM (#10235413)
Yeah,except you forgot to account for

* electricity

* labor

* bandwidth

* cooling

* servers, routers, wiring, and other infrastructure

* taxes on everything

* rent

* insurance