Re:A password hash storage scheme that prevents efficient pa...
by akerl_ on Thursday September 17, 2015 @08:23AM
(#10232901)
It does use data provided from outside: you either need to provide enough valid passwords for it to recreate the secret, or leak data from the stored secrets, as described here:
https://github.com/PolyPasswordHasher/PolyPasswordHasher#if-...
Re:A password hash storage scheme that prevents efficient pa...
by leni536 on Thursday September 17, 2015 @03:26PM
(#10235515)
They leak data but their threat model involves that the attacker can get this leaked data too (they leak it to the hard disk?).
>provide enough passwords
Why don't they just store some dummy users' (with zero privileges) credentials directly on the hard drive? They simply can provide valid passwords from it after reboot and your attacker can have these passwords since they can't do anything with them. Maybe their leak strategy involves something like this?
From the paper:
> The server will restart periodically. All data kept in memory is lost at this point and the server must restart using only the data on disk – which is attacker visible.
So I guess your solution is correct and trivial but the author's solution doesn't use data from outside, not even a user provided symmetric key.