News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Dissent,' a New Type of Security Tool, Could Improve Onl... by nickpsecurity on Thursday September 17, 2015 @12:20AM (#10231545)
Public anonymity has many uses:

https://www.torproject.org/about/torusers.html.en

Most of these are positive. Majority of criminal activity is not on Tor or anonymity networks: just regular Internet. Well, actually boardrooms, streets, and people's homes but the Internet too. ;)

In any case, we don't rid ourselves of a tool because the corrupt can use it. To support your examples, we'd have to eliminate cameras, any tool for making art, all storage mechanisms, and all transmission mechanisms. We don't because the benefits are worth whatever occasional abuse happens. Applies to Tor, too. Especially true when your opponent has significant resources. Even mighty NSA, per Snowden slides, were having quite a bit of trouble despite near global visibility into network traffic. An easy-to-deploy version of that with huge crowds to get lost in is both useful for many people and effective if used correctly.

Unfortunately, the limited take-up means using it makes you stand out. I pointed this out back when people asked why I use custom methods (example [2]) instead of Tor. Plus, the endpoints weren't secure so I figured it would be beaten by the compromise of a number of nodes which send data back to those in control. So, not safe against the strongest attackers. Made a design strategy [2] for high assurance Tor but I doubt it will get implemented. Software is still useful against lesser attackers, though. So, I keep it around. Hopefully get more takeup to give attackers more difficulty.

Note: I just got another example in my news feed about why private by default can be helpful. Texas school and authorities messed a kid up because he was in possession of a homemade clock. Tracing his work to his real identity is why his life might never be the same. Otherwise, it would've been some scary messages on the Internet. :O Add in illegal NSA spying, mapping of social networks, parallel construction, Patriot Act, torture flights, secret courts w/ secret interpretations of law, civil forfeiture, a rigged system that leads to 97% plea rate... there's plenty for Americans to worry about if they're not a favored class with picture-perfect life. The less all these assholes, government or not, know about us the safer we are. I'll add that it's the theory behind the Fourth and Fifth Amendments, too.

[1] https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/08/the_security_...

[2] https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/09/identifying_d...

There are no comments on this comment yet.