News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Dissent,' a New Type of Security Tool, Could Improve Onl... by lisper on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @04:53PM (#10229779)
It's a wonderful theory, but here's an actual data point: when I was at JPL, in the very early days of the internet (mid-to-late 90's), they set up an internal usenet newsgroup, and they set it up so that by default all posts were anonymous. The group was only accessible by JPL employees. The express purpose was so that employees could state their views freely without fear of reprisals.

It was an unmitigated disaster. It basically degenerated into the on-line equivalent of lord-of-the-flies, with some of the the most vicious flame-fests I have ever seen (and I've seen some real conflagrations). They eventually removed the anonymity-by-default and all the vitriol ended instantly.

Two interesting facts:

1. The "anonymity" wasn't real anonymity. The server simply rewrote the "from" header in each message to be from anonymous (which, of course, made things very confusing)

2. After "anonymity" was turned off, it was still trivial to spoof a "from" header and achieve the same level of anonymity as before. But no one did.

I do not deny that anonymity can be useful in some circumstances. But it's no panacea.

There are no comments on this comment yet.