Re:'Dissent,' a New Type of Security Tool, Could Improve Onl...
by lisper on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @04:26PM
(#10229616)
Yes, of course it helps. My point is just that anonymity is neither necessary nor sufficient, and so there might be better ways to accomplish the actual goal, and anonymity should not be the end of the discussion. That's all.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:'Dissent,' a New Type of Security Tool, Could Improve Onl...
by nickpsecurity on Thursday September 17, 2015 @12:37AM
(#10231597)
You're pushing that anonymity is the end of the discussion by fighting it continuously without pushing a better alternative. The NSA slides show that Tor-backed anonymity worked better than I thought it would. It's helping all kinds of people in pro-surveillance and censorship states. So, it's a working solution for many.
What's your alternative again that the average person can easily do without a lot of legal risk or technical knowledge?
Re:'Dissent,' a New Type of Security Tool, Could Improve Onl...
by AnthonyMouse on Thursday September 17, 2015 @12:55AM
(#10231646)
> My point is just that anonymity is neither necessary nor sufficient
It may not be sufficient but it is clearly necessary in cases where attaching your meatspace identity would get political dissidents arrested or killed.
And the pedantry regarding anonymous vs. pseudonymous communication is quite irrelevant. You can send a pseudonymous message over an anonymous network by signing it and you can send an anonymous message over a pseudonymous network by creating a new pseudonym for each message. They're fungible.