Who would you prefer to have designing and selecting standards for exchanging financial information?
"Secure" to banks means, only secure enough for them... I just believe that the future (think 25 years, minimum) is that every single activity of every single person will be tracked in detail to a level which we can't even understand now.
Wait until all your activity is then predicted and compared to actual to refine the tracking. And banks will be doing HFT based on the actual and projected minute-by-minute actions of billions of people...
What if a stock will fluctuate based on lunch time buying surges and after work happy hour, and birthday ties to kids having a birthday on Saturday and their social networks socioeconomic propensity to buy stuff for them last minute at stores r us?
What's wrong with this?
The entire momentum of the stock HFT market is skewed against everyone except the HFT masters...
how about, perhaps, build an engine that can do this and allow for people to buy into slices of it??
I just think that we are literally on the precipice where we will shrink from a perceived "1%" in power to a ".000001%" in power...
Ten years tops...
Even today, in the world of HFTs, this isn't the case. Long-term positions are still valid.
The common man was eliminated from regular trading a very long time ago. I don't see what's to complain about.
I think democratically elected governments would be much better. Banks will design something that serves their interests only, merely overlooking other priorities in some cases and actively promoting their own in others. It's human nature, and also they have a long track record of sacrificing all other interests, including those of the global economy, taxpayers, consumers, and even their own clients.
No institution is perfect, but at least a much broader range of people have a seat at the table government.
Do you want TCP/IP re-designed by popular vote?
You're not able to directly make a shit tonne of money at others expense by contributing to TCP/IP standards.
Not true for anything banks are doing.
Just look at the LIBOR debacle as one datapoint.
I have zero trust in big banks colluding on things that have the potential to affect finances for centuries to come.
Change my view?
Edit: anyone who down voted me hasn't been paying attention to the financial history of banks. Just because YC is tied to finance as an investment POV - you'd be deluded to think that banks aren't corrupt to the core. Do I really need to provide you with evidence, how about look at the last fifteen years for simplicity. Then look into BCCI which I doubt many HNers are even aware of...
HSBC? Wachovia? Jesus, do any of you know how fucking corrupt banks are??