"Claiming Enterprise locations are in bad parts of town may be true where you live."
I think it's a near-universal occurrence. Traditional car rentals are based on warehousing cars at airports and on low-cost land elsewhere. Car sharing is based on cars parked within walking distance.
Zipcar isn't really structured for trip rentals. It's for regular but infrequent secondary transportation. The membership, application, and cost make sense for that use case.
I live in SOMA (San Francisco) on Folsom between 3rd Street & 2nd street. There is an Enterprise on Folsom between 3rd Street & Folsom, right next to Twitter. Draw your own conclusions.
* Claiming Enterprise locations are in bad parts of town may be true where you live. There's one a block from me, in a very nice part of town.
* Leaving out the fact that Zipcar requires an application to join (which takes days to process).
* Zipcar requires a $50 annual membership + $25 per family member
* A spotless driving record and that you've had your license for over 1 year.
* Enterprise is cheaper in many cases (always if you have your own insurance that covers a rental).
Zipcar seems like a cool little company, and I hope they destroy Enterprise. Right now they're a bit lame in a few areas.