News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Welcome to the Block Party: The internet after ad blocking by buffoon on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @02:15AM (#10219218)
I love the mantra of "the web is supported by advertising" that every one of these sorts of articles at least quotes. It's not. Shitty business models are supported by advertising. There are plenty of us who provide non-advertising driven services that are profitable and can afford transit costs.

As for blocking, the technology allows it so I will use it. If it doesn't allow it, I have no ethical qualms about breaking it until it does. If I'm paying for the portal device be it tablet, desktop, smartphone, TV, I will be in control of it. If it's subsidy-driven, their funeral.

Re:Welcome to the Block Party: The internet after ad blocking by jgianakopoulos on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @02:30AM (#10219249)
The mantra? This is how the majority of the web is monetized. It's not a mantra, it's a fact. People contribute content to the web and you pay with viewing ads. I don't know how you can rationalize that as being a "shitty" business model just because you purchase a device that is capable of connecting to the internet.

If what you really mean to say is that it's a bad business model because people like yourself can install ad-blocking software and consume content without paying for it, then I see what you're saying although you come off as entitled and naive.

Re:Welcome to the Block Party: The internet after ad blocking by buffoon on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @03:32AM (#10219415)
Thats really not how it works. Content providers like that ideal but it's incorrect. It never has operated that way.

I pay for a connection and a device. I don't pay for an advertising subsidy. If you choose to use advertising as a capital model for your business in a market so easily destroyed by technology then that by definition is a shitty business model due to the massive risk of a technological shift destroying your only income. Not only that, the consumers merely tolerate your model, not engage it. It is a plague upon them most of the time.

The only way this model works is if you provide a device which consumes advertising. That in itself is being eroded as well due to the number of services which offer utility without advertising even on the advertiser's territory.

Content isn't worth much on its own which is the problem. Authors rarely get paid anything significant from publishing; same with content driven advertising. I don't see how you're going to milk it in a decaying market.

The web will shrink, content will have to stand alone and be free of advertising ties and you'll have to put some cash down for services. Back to 1995 again.

I fully expect these dying markets to throw a few turds yet however. That will merely bury them deeper.

Re:Welcome to the Block Party: The internet after ad blocking by jgianakopoulos on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @12:23PM (#10221508)
If ad blocking keeps growing at the rate it has been, then you're correct and the web will shrink. Maybe people will pay for services or news, and maybe they won't. I do agree that some ads are intrusive and annoying, but the model of publishers using advertising as a revenue source isn't going away any time soon.

What I think is disappointing is that the quantity and quality of original content would suffer without advertising-based business models. Individual bloggers, niche news outlets, and other small publishers will be unable to monetize their content. Even the New York Times (one of the most respected and largest news outlets in the entire world) can barely get over 800,000 paying online subscribers, and that includes subscriptions for a slimmed-down NYT Now app.

If you want a web that is rich in information, then advertising is a devil you have to accept.

Re:Welcome to the Block Party: The internet after ad blocking by tertius on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @12:35PM (#10221581)
So what you're suggesting is one of two things.

1. Support model. I.e. I donate to your site and then consume your content. 2. Netflix (walled garden) model: I pay a central place, think AOL, or Facebook and they track my views and pay those producing content.

Re:Welcome to the Block Party: The internet after ad blocking by buffoon on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @02:41PM (#10222420)
I'm not really suggesting, just acknowledging the inevitability of.
Re:Welcome to the Block Party: The internet after ad blocking by jay_kyburz on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @03:39AM (#10219430)
I'm with Buffoon on this one.

Trying to convince somebody they want to buy something by bombarding them with ads on every web page is shitty. I don't want to be exposed to it. I don't want my kids exposed to it.

Then to build your content business on top of the shitty advertising industry that seems kind of a bad idea.

I think if people want your content they will pay. Publishers just need to bundle it the right way.

And I've said it a few times here on HN, but if we as a society think news and current affairs is important, we shouldn't trust it to commercial organisations driven by profit, we need independent, publicly funded news like Australia's ABC.

Re:Welcome to the Block Party: The internet after ad blocking by sangnoir on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @05:02AM (#10219633)
> I think if people want your content they will pay. Publishers just need to bundle it the right way.

This is incredibly difficult to do and all the attempts I am aware of have 'failed' by varying degrees (paywalls, app.net).

If ad-blocking becomes a trend, I hope the websites as the blockers to pay instead of resorting to "native ads" or going out of business. Hopefully, the internet won't be stratified (rich vs. poor peoples versions of the web), but who am I kidding - happens in all other industries.

However, my opinion is likely coloured by my circumstances: I am a biased 3rd-worlder. I'd prefer the status-quo and have the content I consume subsidised by ads targeted at the western middle class. I would not afford to pay for all the content I find interesting on the internet, especially now with the horrendous USD exchange rate.

Re:Welcome to the Block Party: The internet after ad blocking by jay_kyburz on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @07:25AM (#10219982)
So Paywalls and app.net failed. I can think of heaps of better ideas for packaging news and other content.

I would like to see some of the lessons we have learnt about Freemium applied to news.

First you have a base level of great content available for free for everybody. You build a very large user base. Then for those people who want to dig deeper, you have premium content. Those users who really value your service won't mind spending a little money to engage more. Those who engage a lot - pay a lot, but it's their hobby, their past time. they don't mind.

It sound horrible when you spell it out explicitly, but like everything you need present well.

10c to read an article 1 hour earlier than everybody else. 10c to comment on an article. 5c to read the full transcripts of interviews. 10c to download full res photos. 5c to read full bio's of the people involved in the article.

You could spend $20 a day interacting / socialising / enjoying your news and entertainment.

Re:Welcome to the Block Party: The internet after ad blocking by jgianakopoulos on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @12:33PM (#10221566)
I'm fairly certain this has all been tried. The New York Times and many other news outlets do have a freemium model of sorts. You are allowed access to 10 news articles a month, and after you reach your limit you can pay for more.

Guess how many people subscribe to the Times and are willing to actually pay to read another article? <830,000 worldwide. Paywalls have been implemented, monetization models have been tweaked - you can't change habits. People are habituated to getting their content online for free. They're not willing to pay for it in the vast majority of cases.

If we're talking online news content, there's just a ton of different outlets and I don't see people being willing to pay individually on an article-by-article basis. Maybe if you aggregated content under one subscription model (like the music industry does wit Spotify, Apple Music, etc.) and distributed revenue to publishers based on readership, it could work for a small minority of consumers. But even that seems like a stretch.

Re:Welcome to the Block Party: The internet after ad blocking by jay_kyburz on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @04:57PM (#10223156)
Ok, I just went and had a look at the Times website you minimum subscription is around $80USD a year but you can up to around 500USD a year. Lets round 800,000 at 100US a year is 80MM right?

Thats a shit tone of journalists employed if you ask me.

Re:Welcome to the Block Party: The internet after ad blocking by thedz on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @01:52AM (#10224901)
If you actually read the article, it says that the NY Times' operating costs were $1.48 Billion last year. $80 Million would cover a very minor portion of that.
Re:Welcome to the Block Party: The internet after ad blocking by sangnoir on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @04:48AM (#10219595)
> Shitty business models are supported by advertising.

Just because you do not like it doesn't make it a shitty business model: most sports are supported by advertising (e.g. NFL, UEFA). Endorsement deals, sponsoring teams/stadia/leagues and TV rights are just various forms of advertising.

TV shows are also funded by advertising, as is most journalism that is not state-funded (a.ka. propaganda).

Re:Welcome to the Block Party: The internet after ad blocking by buffoon on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @05:44AM (#10219722)
TV doesn't have ad blockers though.
Re:Welcome to the Block Party: The internet after ad blocking by tertius on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @01:16PM (#10221820)
Tivo?