News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by twblalock on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:00PM (#10217136)
I think that stuff like this and code boot camps, rather than online distance learning, is the real threat to traditional higher education.

In my time in academia, I was always struck by how uncomfortable academics were with the idea of university educations being vocational training, rather than education "for its own sake." It's a nice ideal, but almost all students, especially those in STEM fields, are in college to improve their career prospects. But academics are mainly focused on replicating themselves, i.e. focusing on teaching things that are useful to students who plan to attend graduate school in the field, but not useful to the majority of students who do not. This is how we end up with CS grads who can implement obscure data structures they will never use in industry but cannot do practical things like use version control or continuous integration, or write good unit tests.

For someone who wants to work in a technical field, I think new programs like this one, or like code boot camps, are becoming increasingly attractive as college tuition becomes more expensive and student loans become more burdensome. If employers are willing to hire graduates of these programs, traditional universities will have trouble attracting students. And they should.

Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by eachro on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:18PM (#10217220)
I have yet to meet a CS graduate from a decent school who hasn't been able to learn version control or write good unit test cases in less than a week.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by strathmeyer on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:24PM (#10217244)
I haven't met a company hiring CS graduates that thinks they can easily learn things; they expect their future employees to have experience with all of their technologies already.

What's scary is that nobody has any clue how to get programming jobs with a CS degree except to get really lucky like they did.

Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by eachro on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:28PM (#10217270)
Is this really the case? I know for a fact that large tech companies like Google, FB, Yahoo, MSFT, Amazon are pretty agnostic with respect to the specific tools and technologies that their prospective candidates can use.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by justathrow2k on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:36PM (#10217311)
Really? I feel like lots of people know how to get a programming job with a CS degree, and you in fact hit the nail on the head in your response, learn the technologies that employers are going to want you to have. Experiences to learn these things aren't very difficult to find, imho.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by fredkbloggs on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:52PM (#10217388)
A CS degree from where? I am sure there are colleges out there that teach CS as mathematics, but in my experience that's very uncommon. Most graduates I've met have done at least some programming using real hardware and software and have been taught how to connect the abstract math to real applications. Not all are qualified to work as engineers, but I don't believe a different course of study would have been them any moreso.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by strathmeyer on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @10:59PM (#10231346)
I went to CMU. We built operating systems in C on SunOS machines. Never seen anything but Microsoft, Java, and Oracle in the real world.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by vonmoltke on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:26PM (#10217261)
In fact, that's the way the rest of (dare I say, real) engineering works: you get the theory and practice in your studies, and the mechanics in your first job. The software industry has been spoiled because, for the purposes of large swaths of it, the mechanics can be self-learned by motivated people with or without a degree. The degree (computer science or software engineering) is not supposed to teach the mechanics.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by InclinedPlane on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:28PM (#10217273)
I have. I found very little correlation between having a CS degree and being able to code your way out of a paper bag, with exceptions for some specific colleges.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by eli_gottlieb on Monday September 14, 2015 @05:13PM (#10217495)
Well, computer science is not software engineering, and there's only so much time in a BSc program to teach one or the other.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by rbshadel on Monday September 14, 2015 @05:44PM (#10217709)
I've been thinking how interesting (fun and a little mean) it would be to teach a Software Development class where you - assign groups of students that don't really get along, - have groups consume APIs written by previous groups, - change the assignment (slightly or significantly) every week or so, - constantly email students asking if they could "just make one little tweak" - etc...

If you were completely up front about expectations (this is about learning the processes/pitfalls of software development, not about submitting a polished assignment at the end) maybe you could give students a sense of the skills needed to succeed not just at computer science, but software dev as well.

Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by eli_gottlieb on Monday September 14, 2015 @08:31PM (#10218323)
>I've been thinking how interesting (fun and a little mean) it would be to teach a Software Development class where you - assign groups of students that don't really get along, - have groups consume APIs written by previous groups, - change the assignment (slightly or significantly) every week or so, - constantly email students asking if they could "just make one little tweak" - etc...

Sounds like CS320 at UMass Amherst. We all considered it one of the most work-intensive courses in the degree.

Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by lemmon7 on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:07PM (#10217164)
"coder boot camps" are for suckers.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by WalterSear on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:16PM (#10217207)
Suckers like the 3 excellent, well paid, junior engineers that I work with every day, who are doing a bang up job.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by enahs-sf on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:18PM (#10217223)
From my experiences interviewing candidates from Hack Reactor, GA, Code School/Academy, et al, i'd say, results not typical.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by timr on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:28PM (#10217269)
To be fair, you don't really know what his beginners are "banging up". It simply doesn't take much skill to use a web framework to generate database-backed webpages (witness the rise of the "javascript programmer").

The bootcamps are cranking out a commodity product for a commodity world.

Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by johan_larson on Monday September 14, 2015 @05:31PM (#10217622)
It's not like it is the first time this has happened. EDS (remember them?) had so much demand for programmers back in the mainframe days that they resorted to hiring people with no knowledge of computers, pushing them through a three/four-month course in programming, and them putting them to work as junior coders.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by sotojuan on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:54PM (#10217398)
That is interesting, because I am a CS student and that's exactly want I want to start my career with (web development). I do a lot of React on my own and have some Rails background.

It seems like entry-level jobs in that area, between other CS majors, bootcamp grads, and self-taught developers, are going to get tough to get.

Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by WalterSear on Monday September 14, 2015 @05:57PM (#10217780)
Actually, IMHO, it's easier than ever. Supply can't keep up with demand, and anyone who can show demonstrable skills via a portfolio of relevant personal projects and the demonstrable practical knowledge is on the fast track.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by sotojuan on Monday September 14, 2015 @07:20PM (#10218114)
That's good to know. Thanks!
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by rdudek on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:58PM (#10217423)
I guess it may also depend on the individual. Some people will do better and learn better from those camps. Majority probably get suckered into it as some holy grail of career change, not knowing what they're getting themselves into.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by tariqali34 on Monday September 14, 2015 @05:50PM (#10217740)
Ideally, you will learn from a bootcamp how to self-teach yourself, so you would not need to spend more money on a second bootcamp.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by apta on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:20PM (#10217229)
Web developers?
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by justathrow2k on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:34PM (#10217299)
Out of curiosity, why do you ask if they are web developers?
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by kedean on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:50PM (#10217377)
Because that's largely what boot camps focus on. They are there to teach you what's popular right now, which is web dev. They aren't going to teach you kernel development, or backend application development, or graphics skills, because that's not what 'omgstartups' are hiring for.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by apta on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:54PM (#10217400)
Exactly. Not to mention "not hip" things like security, performance sensitive code, distributed systems, HCI, solid understanding of computing theory, and so on.

Web devs tend to be easily replaceable, so why not hire a bunch of juniors (at a cheap cost) to get the job done? This is what it seems these types of "academies" are targeting anyway. Like "timr" said in this thread: "... a commodity product for a commodity world."

Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by justathrow2k on Monday September 14, 2015 @05:05PM (#10217459)
Fair enough, but I don't see how any of this has to do with the topic at hand, which was boot camps are for suckers. I wouldn't consider the junior developers who are working out well in the parents reply suckers - sounds like they're employed and working out well.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by Kalium on Monday September 14, 2015 @05:34PM (#10217645)
They bought a product (bootcamp) in the pursuit of a career in software engineering. Odds are they aren't equipped for more than a series of jobs doing webdev scut work.

"Suckers" might be a bit strong, but their expectations may suffer a certain misalignment with reality.

Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by justathrow2k on Monday September 14, 2015 @06:39PM (#10217976)
That's a bit presumption of you, perhaps all they wanted to be was someone who does 'webdev scut work'.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by Kalium on Monday September 14, 2015 @06:54PM (#10218036)
It's possible! But I've also talked to a number of bootcamp grads and students. Most of them have dreams of doing more than basic webdev.

Of course, it's possible that those were outliers. The population is clearly non-zero, though.

Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by twblalock on Monday September 14, 2015 @05:37PM (#10217668)
I know web devs who have taught themselves CS fundamentals and the stuff you mentioned, but they started with boot camp doing Rails. And why not? They were able to teach themselves this stuff while working for a good salary and getting experience for their resume.
Re:For Silicon Valley Hopefuls, Is College Irrelevant? by arnamak on Monday September 14, 2015 @04:37PM (#10217318)
Damn, guess I'm a sucker for trying to better myself by attending 9 weeks of fun/education leading to an awesome job that I love.

How could I have been so foolish!