Re:A Simple Proof That Pi Is Irrational
by jordigh on Monday September 14, 2015 @03:07PM
(#10216836)
That just wraps up a mystery inside another. Why would tan(x) be irrational if x is rational? That seems like an even bigger mystery than why π is irrational.
It's all mysteries. The point of "simple" is to create a series of simple steps, each step should be straight forward and easy to understand.
Terse != simple
Re:A Simple Proof That Pi Is Irrational
by dnautics on Monday September 14, 2015 @03:19PM
(#10216893)
Thats easy if you remember arctan(y/x) is the angle from x axis to (x,y)
I fail to see how this helps. Actual proof is more complicated, it is based on continued fractions.
> Of course, the proof for (tan(x) is irrational for rational x != 0) might be complicated
> The first rigorous proof that π is irrational is from Johann Heinrich Lambert in 1761. He proved that if x≠0 is rational, then tan(x) must be irrational. Since tan(π/4)=1 is rational, then π must be irrational.
Of course, the proof for (tan(x) is irrational for rational x != 0) might be complicated, but at least it's easy to see why this proves that PI is irrational.
This one, on the other hand, I can't even follow in principle what it's trying to say.
That's of course because I don't understand integrals and differentials.