News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by jordyhoyt on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:05PM (#1021168)
Very good, somehow hadn't seen this yet. Thanks!

If all comments on HN were disagreements, this could be an interesting alternative to the simple karma score of a comment. Better yet, f we could tease the concepts of each level away from the disagreement element, we could have an interesting way of classifying comments. Maybe a Conversational Hierarchy:

CH0 - Attack on a person

CH1 - Statement concerning a person

CH2 - Statement concerning a text

CH3 - Statement concerning a point made

CH4 - Reasoning/facts concerning a point made

CH5 - Reasoned response to a point made

CH6 - Reasoned response to the central point

5 and 6 could use a bit of beefing up, but you get the idea. They could each have karma scores assigned to them (negative for 0-2, neutral for 3, positive for 4-6) and the classification with the most votes wins. The "CH" appended to the beginning of the number makes it so noobs would be likely to the time to learn what they mean. The UI for this would have to be dead simple, maybe a dropdown.

Thoughts?

Re:Welcome to HN: A refresher course on how to disagree... ... by chronomex on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:13PM (#1021332)
The only issue I see right now with this is that it doesn't promote interesting but (strictly speaking) off-topic discussions.