Re:Nokia: Every Apple product infringes on our patents
by boucher on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:31PM
(#1021239)
But are standards committee members actually bound by promises they made to said committees? In other words, as members of the organization did they sign a legally binding contract?
It may be a jackass thing to do, but if they aren't actually legally obligated to license under "fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory" then the standards argument won't hold any water.
Re:Nokia: Every Apple product infringes on our patents
by delayclose on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:45PM
(#1021275)
I doubt Nokia is willing to burn the bridges with standardization bodies like that.
In order for standards committees to work without degenerating into a self serving orgy of "hide the patent requirement" the players generally agree to this. RAMBUS is a good example of why this is needed.
This may come down to: Does Nokia have patents, which are not covered by any of their standards obligations, that Apple is infringing. I expect there are some or Apple would not also have the "not valid" card on the table. Apple's pockets are deep enough to fight a patent validity suit.
Meanwhile, Nokia will be doing the same in reverse for Apple's patents, except that Apple won't have the "reasonable and non-discriminatory" obligation.