...is designed to insult or discredit the author without any reference to the actual argument (or any objective facts.) If the goal is to move the discussion forward, how can this be "a reasonable assertion"?
In most cases you are probably calling the person a "dilettante" or "self-important" without really knowing the person. And chances are such labels will be emotionally, rather than rationally motivated. So it's true that in some cases the claim can be legitimate, but given our setting in an almost anonymous internet discussion place, it's unlikely that those claims are ever founded on reason. I think that was Paul's point: that calling someone a "fag" vs "self-important dilettante" are similar in their usually unfounded bases. You're correct in that there is a fundamental difference because calling someone a "fag" is not only unfounded, it's also derogatory as well as irrelevant to any rational argument (irrelevant, unless it is an argument about their sexuality).
>u r a fag!!!!!!!!!!
>But it's important to realize that more articulate name-calling has just as little weight. A comment like
>The author is a self-important dilettante.
>is really nothing more than a pretentious version of "u r a fag."
I completely disagree. One is a direct verbal attack, the other can very possibly be a reasonable assertion. If it's followed by a fair explanation, all the better.