Re:Anti-Competitive Effects of Common Ownership [pdf]
by avivo on Sunday September 13, 2015 @02:40PM
(#10212346)
The thesis is ~ that just having the same inactive institutional investors owning shares in competing companies discourages competition and hurts consumers.
I highly recommend reading the conclusion -- some excerpts/context:
"Consolidation in the asset management industry has potentially large anti-competitive effects, even compared to mergers of natural competitors in the product market itself. "
"Consistent with investors’ economic incentives and established economic theory, we find that when firms don’t have incentives to compete, they don’t. Specifically, we use more than 10 years of market-firm-level panel data from the airline industry to show that common ownership has a large and significant positive effect on product prices."
Re:Anti-Competitive Effects of Common Ownership [pdf]
by kspaans on Sunday September 13, 2015 @03:36PM
(#10212527)
I wonder if this could lead to firms like Vanguard and BlackRock not using their proxy votes. Or perhaps creating a system where index fund investors get to vote based on the shares they indirectly own. E.g. my 1000 shares of VTI means I get 10 votes at Apple shareholder meetings.
Re:Anti-Competitive Effects of Common Ownership [pdf]
by seiji on Sunday September 13, 2015 @05:47PM
(#10212903)
This is one thing the "little people" know, but can do nothing about because all the billionaires are colluding to protect themselves.
I've seen companies decide to not work on a project because one of the board members runs another company doing something similar. It's silly all the way down.
I highly recommend reading the conclusion -- some excerpts/context: "Consolidation in the asset management industry has potentially large anti-competitive effects, even compared to mergers of natural competitors in the product market itself. "
"Consistent with investors’ economic incentives and established economic theory, we find that when firms don’t have incentives to compete, they don’t. Specifically, we use more than 10 years of market-firm-level panel data from the airline industry to show that common ownership has a large and significant positive effect on product prices."
This is fascinating, especially in light of the analysis of "The Network of Global Corporate [Ownership]" http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.... -- it explores the graph/structure of ownership among the largest organizations.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10009740
I've seen companies decide to not work on a project because one of the board members runs another company doing something similar. It's silly all the way down.