Re:What the Kapors Have Learned from Years of Working on Div...
by jdp23 on Saturday September 12, 2015 @02:25PM
(#10208831)
No, I'm not implying a logical disconnect; I'm saying that if your goal is diversity, the notion of a "meritocracy" gets in the way. More in my comment at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10208825
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:What the Kapors Have Learned from Years of Working on Div...
by ebfe on Saturday September 12, 2015 @02:44PM
(#10208884)
The goal isn't diversity, though. The goal is meritocracy, with diversity only desirable insofar as it enables meritocracy.
Re:What the Kapors Have Learned from Years of Working on Div...
by jdp23 on Saturday September 12, 2015 @03:14PM
(#10208975)
Speak for yourself. Many people who benefit from the current systemic biases would agree with you; many people who don't -- and some think society as a whole would be better if the systemic biases were reduced -- see thins differently.
> The goal is meritocracy, with diversity only desirable insofar as it enables meritocracy.
In other words "The goal is anti-diversity, with diversity only desirable insofar as it enables the anti-diversity goal."
Re:What the Kapors Have Learned from Years of Working on Div...
by douche on Saturday September 12, 2015 @04:25PM
(#10209235)
The goal is to get shit done. If diversity enables you to get shit done better than non-diversity, then let's be diverse.
The old great metaphor for America was that it was a "melting pot." The metaphor comes from smelting. When you smelt metal, you're not promoting diversity - you're creating a homogeneous alloy. You also skim off the slag and throw it out.
It's not a particularly pleasant metaphor when you think about it.
Re:What the Kapors Have Learned from Years of Working on Div...
by AnthonyMouse on Saturday September 12, 2015 @04:17PM
(#10209203)
> In other words "The goal is anti-diversity, with diversity only desirable insofar as it enables the anti-diversity goal."
Meritocracy is not anti-diversity. Meritocracy is correlated with diversity. Choosing meritocracy where they diverge is nothing more than accepting that diversity is not the one true goal of all things.