News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Elsevier, that just freaked me out by jcrawfordor on Saturday September 12, 2015 @04:53AM (#10207630)
In this case there was no faking of the vendor installed. HID is a generic input class, you're not making any promise about who manufactured a device when you make it represent as HID.

A lot of people seem to think that this was a device with hacked or other illegitimate firmware. It was not. It was a device called a WebKey, which is available from a number of vendors and is intended to do exactly what the author is describing.

Is it a dumb product? Yes. But this is not any kind of firmware exploit. It's just a keyboard that doesn't look like a keyboard, some as a YubiKey or one of several other sorts of non-keyboard devices that present as keyboards.

Re:Elsevier, that just freaked me out by acdha on Saturday September 12, 2015 @10:04AM (#10208100)
Right, note that up-thread (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10204222) I was agreeing with the general call for OS safeguards such as confirming that a particular device be allowed to act as a particular class.

Signatures become relevant due to what will inevitably happen if those safeguards become common: right now someone is selling devices like this to marketing people. If Windows 11 breaks that with a permission check, the companies have the choice of either dropping that product or changing it to pretend to be a Microsoft USB keyboard on the whitelist. If it's some fly-by-night marketing services company in China, there's limited recurse to go after them unless you have a lever such as being able to revoke signing keys.