News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Scientific Scandal of Antismoking by maxklein on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @11:49AM (#1020723)
That page is on a website offered for free from an ISP. That's the universal home for all conspiracy theories nuts.
Re:The Scientific Scandal of Antismoking by damienkatz on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @12:26PM (#1020803)
Yes, but are the claims true? Have studies failed to show stopping smoking doesn't help you live longer?

And the Japanese _are_ fairly heavy smokers yet have very long lives.

That's not to say I don't thinking smoking is really bad for you. It's an addictive drug, reduces lung capacity and I've known people being treated for emphysema in their 30's etc. But the article makes some interesting claims about how politically charged the issue around smoking is, real science is getting squelched, people ask earnest questions and have their sanity questioned.

Don't know if any of it's true, but with the Global Warming "science" we've been seeing lately, it wouldn't surprise me if the risk of cigarettes has been way oversold.

Re:The Scientific Scandal of Antismoking by patrickas on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @01:04PM (#1020904)
I think the claims are true, but the headline and content is a bit over dramatized.

Here are the studies, you can draw your own conclusions:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1573365

"The subjects were 1445 male smokers, initially aged 40-59 years" ... 20 years later "total mortality was 7% lower" for people who stopped smoking (7% is barely significant given the sample size)

And also http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT00000487

Showing similar results.

Re:The Scientific Scandal of Antismoking by elai on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @01:14PM (#1020926)
How about people who start smoking in their teens, and then stop in their early/mid twenties? The effects of quitting smoking then would probably far more beneficial than a smoker who's been smoking for 30 years and then quits.
Re:The Scientific Scandal of Antismoking by hga on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @02:22PM (#1021069)
Based on a variety of things including an statement by my favorite professor, I think it's not so much that smoking is deadly by itself, but smoking and most anything else is, e.g.:

He said smoking in the context of a city's pollution was very bad, that e.g. Kansas wheat farmers had problems related to the wheat farming but were otherwise OK (he was an M.D. and smoked, BTW, took lots of Vitamin A and so on and he'll turn 90 next year...).

It's well established (to my satisfaction, at least) that radon is mostly dangerous in the context of heavy smoking (which after all is where the initial study came from, of uranium miners).

The risks of smoking and lots of things like birth control pills are well established.

I'd also note that there's going to be genetic variability here that will make smoking much worse for some fraction of the population.

(On the other hand, as someone with severe allergies, I'm not entirely unhappy with the results of the US crusade against smoking....)

Re:The Scientific Scandal of Antismoking by brazzy on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @05:36AM (#1022257)
> And the Japanese _are_ fairly heavy smokers yet have very long lives.

That's funny because I was going to write "I don't know how much truth is in what he writes about all those studies, but that statememt is complete bullshit". I've lived in Japan for a year, and my personal experience is that the Japanese smoke very little.

Re:The Scientific Scandal of Antismoking by jawngee on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @01:00PM (#1020893)
Probably because their diets are vastly superior to everyone else's. So people predisposed to live longer are going to live longer, even if smoking takes a few years off their lives.
Re:The Scientific Scandal of Antismoking by byrneseyeview on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @12:08PM (#1020766)
Yeah, but they picked such an honest, respectable-looking font.
Re:The Scientific Scandal of Antismoking by wheels on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @01:50AM (#1022096)
It's apparently by a fairly widely published biologist, an expert on fish eyes, it would seem:

http://www.google.com/search?q=%22J.+R.+JOHNSTONE%22+monash

Re:The Scientific Scandal of Antismoking by herdrick on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @02:22AM (#1022126)
Isn't that a funny correlation? It's not like that's the easiest way to publish something on the web. I wonder what's going on here.