News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by morganvachon on Thursday September 10, 2015 @09:44PM (#10201562)
A nitpick (beyond the spelling, grammar, and punctuation errors throughout): The part about "most states in the Union require 24 hours before reporting a missing person" is nothing but a Hollywood trope. The fact is, most agencies require a missing person to be entered into their respective state's database within a few hours of the report. I can say unequivocally that Georgia has a two-hour window, as I've entered many such reports during my stint in law enforcement, and that is our state's requirement.

The reason they want to enter the person as soon as possible is so that any checks for that person's info will return a "hit" in time to locate the person. For example, George has dementia, goes for a walk at 8am, and is gone for several hours. He is reported missing at 12pm, and the police report is keyed into the state database by 1pm. At 2pm that same day, George is stopped by an officer and his information ran on the state computer. A hit shows up that states he's a missing-endangered person (endangered due to his mental state), the officer notifies his department so they can notify the family, and all is well. Now, if the bogus 24 hour rule was real, George never would have been reported the day he went missing, and perhaps would have met a grisly demise that night. Timely reporting is a potentially life-saving measure and I really wish television and the movies would stop it with that particularly dangerous bit of misinformation.

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by anigbrowl on Thursday September 10, 2015 @11:29PM (#10201866)
It's a trope with a basis in fact - that used to be the standard until relatively recently. I have had occasion to file 2 missing person reports and both times I was told on my first call that the person hadn't been gone long enough to justify a report. Both incidents were >10 years ago and obviously things have changed since then.
Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by morganvachon on Friday September 11, 2015 @05:37AM (#10202771)
Then I would say the agency you called wasn't conforming to their state's regulations and was potentially endangering lives. I worked in law enforcement from 1999 to 2013 and missing persons cases always had a timely entry regulation during that time. My state's regulations are copied nearly verbatim from the federal rules (NCIC).
Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by anigbrowl on Friday September 11, 2015 @05:13PM (#10206221)
As I said, I was talking about the basis in fact rather than in law.
Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by dogma1138 on Friday September 11, 2015 @01:14AM (#10202118)
Depending on the agency and the situation there could be also very different policies regarding this, however I couldn't find a single regulation stating that there's a 24 hour period or that it had been changed.

If you say that an 17 yr old didn't came home they might say it's more likely that they are spending the night at a friend while a 9 yr old kid that didn't came home from school will spark an ember alert very quickly.

But in general the police cannot actually prevent you from filing any type of a report, you can go to any police station and a file a report that aliens have abducted your cat.

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by sliverstorm on Thursday September 10, 2015 @10:45PM (#10201726)
The scope of the operation also grows exponentially (or was it quadratically?) with time. Scent trails and tracks decay quickly, and at a fixed rate of travel the area in which the subject can be grows as time^2 (the area of a circle). At 2mph after 1 hour your subject is within an area of roughly 12 square miles. After 24 hours that area is more than 7000 square miles.

So agencies are generally interested in processing them quickly. That must be balanced against some filtering for bogus reports and incidents likely to resolve themselves, of course.

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by morganvachon on Thursday September 10, 2015 @11:18PM (#10201834)
> Scent trails and tracks decay quickly

This is generally only an issue when it's a case of a missing-endangered subject; most missing persons reports are of a routine[1] nature (spouse is delayed in travel and can't be reached; child has run away for the third time that month). Having a blanket policy that requires timely entry of all reports will cover every scenario, especially since an otherwise routine missing person report can turn into an emergency situation after the initial report is made.

> incidents likely to resolve themselves

That's true, and the vast majority of missing persons reports I entered over a 14 year span were canceled within hours or at most, days, when the missing person returned of their own volition. But the ones who are found safe only as a result of the timely report stand in defense of the policy.

[1] Just as there is no such thing as a "routine" traffic stop and therefore officers should always be alert, there is actually no such thing as a "routine" missing person report either; but for the sake of this discussion, by "routine" in this case I mean "not urgent or endangered".

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by davydka on Thursday September 10, 2015 @11:29PM (#10201867)
Fantastic info. Thanks for sharing that.
[dead]
Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by seibelj on Thursday September 10, 2015 @11:52PM (#10201929)
Reddit would be a better place for comments like this. HN is for reasonable discussion
Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by DanBC on Friday September 11, 2015 @08:20AM (#10203221)
half of the people shot and killed by police are vulnerable people with a mental illness.

It's a reasonable point made in an unhelpful inflammatory way.

In 30th June 2015 WP had this article (reporting that about a quarter of the people shot and killed by US police that year had a mental illness. The police had often been called out by relatives who wanted help, but who didn't want their loved one shot and killed).

Here's a grauniad report that talks about the differing news coverage of US shootings of dogs (lots of coverage) and mentally ill people (local news). I'm not sure that bit is accurate: plenty of dogs are killed by US police with little media mention. http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/apr/03/idaho-police-...

That report talks about the total number of people shot and killed by US police, and about the amount of them who had mental illness, and links to this 2013 PDF that says about 1,000 people are shot and killed by US police each year, and that about half of them have a mental illness. (Scarily the US doesn't collect statistics about this! That's, I think, telling.) http://tacreports.org/storage/documents/2013-justifiable-hom...

> Although no national data is collected, multiple informal studies and accounts support the conclusion that “at least half of the people shot and killed by police each year in this country have mental health problems.”

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by happyscrappy on Friday September 11, 2015 @08:54AM (#10203380)
Suicide by cop is a thing and if you aggressively go after officers it is safe to say you may have a mental illness.
Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by DanBC on Friday September 11, 2015 @09:12AM (#10203448)
Suicide by cop is a thing ... in the US.

People aggressively go after cops in other countries and don't get shot.

It's poor training and low skills that cause US police to kill so many people.

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by dagw on Friday September 11, 2015 @10:36AM (#10203882)
It's poor training and low skills that cause US police to kill so many people.

No it's not poor training, it's just fundamentally different training. The US train their police force that it's OK to draw their weapons and potentially use deadly force in far more situations than the police in for example Europe.

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by elektromekatron on Friday September 11, 2015 @11:21AM (#10204162)
They may be following their training, however "poor" and "fundamentally different" are not mutually exclusive concepts.

The fact that the US train their police force that it's OK to draw their weapons and potentially use deadly force in far more situations than police manage in lots of other countries, would suggest that it is poor training, as many other police forces seem to be much better at de-escalation, and the training given to them seems to be a major component of that.

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by at-fates-hands on Friday September 11, 2015 @10:21AM (#10203796)
>> It's poor training and low skills that cause US police to kill so many people.

This is a total over generalization. Mainly because the numbers of people shot by police do not include the context of the shooting.

Questions like:

- Did the person charge at a police officer?

- Did the person brandish a weapon like a knife or gun and threaten the officer?

- Did the person physically attack the officer?

- Did the person refuse to put down a weapon after being asked several times?

Are not included in a statistical breakdown of police shootings. As such, the number people trot out there simply have no context to show in many cases the officer is justified in using deadly force - where it comes down to it's either the cop dying or the person they're trying to arrest dying. This is probably the one thing that irks the shit of me more than anything. The data about police shootings is unreliable at best, completely inaccurate at worst:

Officials with the Justice Department keep no comprehensive database or record of police shootings, instead allowing the nation’s more than 17,000 law enforcement agencies to self-report officer-involved shootings as part of the FBI’s annual data on “justifiable homicides” by law enforcement.

“The FBI’s justifiable homicides and the estimates from (arrest-related deaths) both have significant limitations in terms of coverage and reliability that are primarily due to agency participation and measurement issues,” said Michael Planty, one of the Justice Department’s chief statisticians, in an email.

Even less data exists for officer-involved shootings that do not result in fatalities.

“We do not have information at the national level for police shootings that result in non-fatal injury or no injury to a civilian,” Planty said.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-nation/wp/2014/09/0...

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by DanBC on Saturday September 12, 2015 @09:11AM (#10207994)
Except we know that people in other countries who use similar weapons in similar ways (brandishing a small knife, refusing to drop it, etc) are not shot and killed by police nearly as often as they are in the US.

A guy weilding a machete and charging police in, say, London is much less likely to be shot and killed by police. (And you can see this on youtube).

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by forgetsusername on Friday September 11, 2015 @11:55AM (#10204383)
>As such, the number people trot out there simply have no context to show in many cases the officer is justified in using deadly force

What exactly is "many"?

Of course deadly force is sometimes justified. But you do realize that civilian deaths at the hands of police are through the roof in the US compared to any other country, right? Is the US population psychotic?

>This is probably the one thing that irks the shit of me more than anything.

What irks the shit out of me are apologists who justify police violence because "sometimes" deadly force is required. Is there anyone in this country that doesn't understand that, as a Police Officer, you're going to end up in scary situations? You're signing up for it. It doesn't give you permission to shoot something every time you feel the least bit threatened.

Hopefully body cameras solve this ridiculous problem.

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by DanBC on Saturday September 12, 2015 @09:19AM (#10208011)
> Is the US population psychotic?

Frustrating that you chose to use word psychotic there.

Psychosis isn't linked to violence. Previous episode of violence are; a drug or alcohol addiction are; and if you combine any (or all) of these you get a stronger predictor. But a person with psychosis is far more likely to be the victim not perpetrator of violent crime, are more likely to hurt themselves than anyone else.

Maybe psychopathic fits, but that's still pretty stigmatising.

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by happyscrappy on Friday September 11, 2015 @02:00PM (#10205177)
>Is the US population psychotic?

The US is by far the most violent Western nation.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intention...

>Hopefully body cameras solve this ridiculous problem.

Body cameras will likely vindicate police more than opponents would like, although it may be hard to compare before and after because knowing you are being recorded will have an affect.

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by rmxt on Friday September 11, 2015 @09:32AM (#10203535)
Your tone suggests that police officers have less agency/responsibility in such a scenario than the people with mental illnesses themselves. Is that actually what you are suggesting?
Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by tripzilch on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @05:54AM (#10219746)
You too, could've made that same statement without taking the unnecessary dig at Reddit. Take it to HN--oh, wait.

No but seriously, it's one (not very nice) thing saying "don't bring Reddit's bad comment quality to HN". It's an entirely other thing to encourage someone to post shitty comments on another site. That behaviour won't fly at Reddit either. Take it to 4chan.

[dead]
Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by seibelj on Friday September 11, 2015 @12:12AM (#10201982)
The comment you responded to was about the utility of quickly filing missing persons reports. Your response said that people with dementia filed as missing would be lucky to survive an encounter with a police officer. It seems like you have an axe to grind that is completely irrelevant to the topic of discussion. I don't know your political inclinations but your arguments are illogical and confusing.

I said it would be better for reddit, because comments like yours are common there, while fairly uncommon on HN

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by DanBC on Friday September 11, 2015 @08:26AM (#10203239)
> Your response said that people with dementia filed as missing would be lucky to survive an encounter with a police officer.

Relatives often call the police when someone with a mental health problem is in distress or has gone for a walk or whatever.

We don't know how many encounters with police end happily. We do know that Many of the encounters that end with a loved one being shot started when a relative called the police.

(Obviously this is in the US. Other countries have plenty of police involvement with mentally ill people, who are sometimes armed with similar weapons to the US cases, that don't end with the ill person being killed.)

I agree with you about how that point is being made.

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by MrJagil on Friday September 11, 2015 @07:29AM (#10203072)
I would say that your stab at reddit was just as meaningless as his initial comment. Why didn't you post what you just posted in the first place? If you really want to help keep HN clean, avoid the snide one-liners. Either leave it at a down-vote or post a proper reply.
Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by mirimir on Friday September 11, 2015 @12:18AM (#10201997)
You posted an ad hominem attack on police in America. That doesn't even belong on reddit, although it's more common there.

That said, police in America are stuck dealing with the consequences of many short-sighted policy decisions. They are not properly trained for social work, mental health services, and so on.

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by ithought on Friday September 11, 2015 @12:59PM (#10204787)
How is that an ad hominem attack?

Most cops aren't properly trained to shoot a gun. Some have 1 training session per year and they have to hit 70% on a target 3 yards away. Most don't seem to know how to react in a confrontation or high-stress situation.

The system is flawed but people have personal responsibility too. You can't absolve someone of criminal acts by saying oh it's someone else's fault.

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by rev_bird on Friday September 11, 2015 @09:08AM (#10203429)
> They are not properly trained for social work, mental health services, and so on.

Seems like another one of those short-sighted policy decisions here...

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by morganvachon on Friday September 11, 2015 @06:34PM (#10206507)
Actually many agencies have begun training their officers to properly recognize and approach mentally/emotionally unstable people to offer them assistance, without resorting to use of force. The academy in my area calls it Crisis Intervention Training, and it is a required course for agencies who train at that facility, which is most of northwest Georgia.
Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by aquateen on Friday September 11, 2015 @12:49AM (#10202065)
Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by bbcbasic on Friday September 11, 2015 @02:55AM (#10202331)
HN Rule 1 - he/she who Latins first ... wins the argument. Game over.
Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by mirimir on Friday September 11, 2015 @03:51AM (#10202472)
De gustibus non disputandem ;)

But what about Sanskrit?

Re:Vanishing Point: How to disappear in America without a tr... by linkydinkandyou on Friday September 11, 2015 @01:44AM (#10202182)
Or Quora! They're all about knee-jerk cop-hate!