News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by ars on Monday December 28, 2009 @06:16PM (#1019616)
Is it legal to record a show? Yes. Is it legal to ask someone to record a show for you? I think yes.

So, how is using a torrent to get a show you have legal access to illegal?

And don't say commercials, since it's perfectly legal to ask/pay someone to record a show for you, while pausing the recording during the commercials.

There is a reason TV studios have never gone after torrent sites, while movies studios have.

Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by tptacek on Monday December 28, 2009 @06:25PM (#1019632)
I'm pretty sure it's not lawful for someone to use their own equipment and their own pay cable feed to record a show and distribute it to someone else. I'm just saying, I don't think "of course it's legal" is the answer to your hypotheticals.

A more plausible reason TV studios don't go after torrent sites, apart from the fact that the TV business is more decentralized, is the fact that torrenting does less damage to them. TV is primarily ad supported. Motion pictures make a large chunk of their money directly off the new release window of the DVD release.

Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by ErrantX on Monday December 28, 2009 @06:41PM (#1019673)
> Is it legal to ask someone to record a show for you? I think yes.

That's possibly illegal; but it's one of those things that has never actually been tested and I cant find any part of the law that actually fully covers such a scenario.

The legal problem with torrents you already pay for access too is probably more founded in that your probably (unless your leeching the torrent ofc) facilitating others to download it - who might not have the access.