News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by nostrademons on Monday December 28, 2009 @05:33PM (#1019531)
Do you have any legal basis for that? Sony vs. Universal Studios (1983) hinged on timeshifting being legitimate fair use: "because the District Court's factual findings reveal that even the unauthorized home time-shifting of respondents' programs is legitimate fair use". If it's legal to timeshift broadcast TV, why would it be illegal for subscription TV?

Similarly, if timeshifting subscription TV is not fair use, then Tivo and all the other DVR makers would exist solely for infringing purposes, and I doubt we'd see them on the market.

IANAL, but I'm guessing that UANAL either, so I'd like to see some evidence that it actually is illegal before being stated as such...

Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by evgen on Monday December 28, 2009 @07:04PM (#1019714)
"Time shifting" is legitimate fair use if you record the shows yourself for your own personal use. If you claim that because the episode you are downloading was at one point in the past shown on broadcast TV you are "time shifting" it then you would not get very far on court.
Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by jrockway on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:30AM (#1020280)
Before we get to court, why don't you decide what crime this is?
Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by chancho on Monday December 28, 2009 @08:55PM (#1019863)
No, neither of us are lawyers (let's keep this http://mattmaroon.com/2009/05/01/hacker-news-disease/ in mind) but since you've cited case law at me, then who am I to ruin an IP law speculation-fest.

Perhaps "it's illegal" is too bold a statement, but I do think that if tptacek got sued by HBO for torrenting True Blood then a fair use defense would not hold up. That's just my not-a-lawyer opinion, and I don't know of any precedent for this fair-use-timeshifting-by-proxy defense (do you?) but hey we might actually see a case like this soon. Last season HBO was monitoring the True Blood torrents and sending out C&D's to the ISPs of all peers with US IP addresses, if the Pirate Bay comments were to be believed.

Anyway, here's my not-a-lawyer reasoning: copyright law grants all rights of copying and distribution to the originator of the work and these are only transferred to a second party by written contract, EXCEPT for fair use (and first sale and other exceptions like that.) According to Wikipedia, fair use is a nebulous thing and varies from case to case but from what I can see it only gives you the right to copy for personal use (Tivo good) and never distribution (torrents bad). In fact Joel Tenenbaum and Jaimie Thomas both tried and failed to use fair-use as a defense for filesharing. So in order for hypothetical HBO v. Tptacek to not be summarily ruled in favor of the plaintiff, tptacek would have to show that his subscription to HBO constituted a contract which granted him the right to acquire and distribute HBO recordings. AND his torrent peers would all have to be HBO subscribers too. I doubt you'll find any language like that on his cable bill.

But what do I know.

Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by tptacek on Monday December 28, 2009 @09:42PM (#1019934)
I resent the implication that I would torrent True Blood.