News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by olegk on Monday December 28, 2009 @05:19PM (#1019505)
Tell that to Google.
Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by grellas on Monday December 28, 2009 @06:07PM (#1019595)
Google is not similarly exposed to liability just because its search function can be used to facilitate infringement.

The issue here is one of potential liability for contributory infringement.

When a party's technology is being primarily used for infringing purposes, and its independent, non-infringing uses are at best marginal, such a party can be held liable for contributory infringement of the copyrights at issue. That in essence appears to be what the court concluded here.

Contributory infringement, though, does not extend to technologies that can only incidentally be used for infringing purposes - were it otherwise, then any technology involved in facilitating an infringing use could be swept in (e.g., the manufacturers of hardware devices used to play the infringing material).

This line of legal reasoning has gradually evolved from the 1980's Betamax case through Napster to a variety of iterations in the modern law. It is a complex area of law but, in essence, it defines a level of culpability by which the law deems it fair to impose liability on a party not directly infringing on copyrighted materials but whose technology facilitates such infringement. Here, the court concluded that IsoHunt was sufficiently culpable to be held liable in spite of the fact that it can be used for innocent purposes as well.

Google's search function, on the other hand, obviously has major uses apart from those facilitating copyright infringement and Google is nowhere close to being a contributory infringer even though its technology might be misused for this purpose.

Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by jellicle on Monday December 28, 2009 @06:55PM (#1019697)
But Google's business is actually 99.99% infringing. Everything is copyrighted, including but not limited to this website. (Under current U.S. law, Federal government publications are nearly the only thing not copyrighted.) In no case has the copyright owner expressed permission for you to copy the copyrighted text to your computer. And yet, that is very very close to 100% of Google's business - locating copyrighted texts and sending users to them in order for those users to copy them, presumably illegally, to their computers. Only in the very rare case (.gov websites, users finding their own websites) is the user not infringing copyright. Nor is it possible for the user to determine whether he/she is infringing copyright; for example, the text on a .gov website could be written by a government contractor and therefore be copyrighted.
Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by grellas on Monday December 28, 2009 @08:04PM (#1019798)
I was not trying to defend the current law or any of its possible inconsistencies but only to give a sense of how it applies to this type of situation - as that law is currently interpreted, there is a near-zero risk that Google's search business will be held to create liabilities for contributory infringement.

That doesn't mean the law is correct and people can reasonably differ on what is or isn't fair under copyright (or even whether copyright should exist) - but that argument is a philosophical one and not one for explaining what the current law is.

Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by vidarh on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @04:57AM (#1020296)
The copyright owner "expressed permission" for a limited degree of copying by making the content available on a publicly accessible website in a form intended for distribution and not utilizing any means to restrict the copying in the first place.

Good luck finding any judge that'd agree with you that Google's business is "99.9% infringing".

Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by metabrew on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @07:26AM (#1020373)
It's worth reading this* paper by the EFF about legal exposure of p2p developers, it talks about contributory infringement and related topics.

* http://www.eff.org/wp/iaal-what-peer-peer-developers-need-kn...

Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by freetard on Monday December 28, 2009 @08:26PM (#1019823)
> When a party's technology is being primarily used for infringing purposes

I guess that means google image search should be forbidden too as most images are copyrighted.

Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by bluedanieru on Monday December 28, 2009 @06:58PM (#1019706)
How is it a complex area of law? It seems to me the law is left ambiguous enough that it can be used to prosecute at the whims of the highest bidder, while making sure that the right parties are never held to the same standard.
Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by jacquesm on Monday December 28, 2009 @07:56PM (#1019789)
UANAL but Grellas is.

If he says it's complex I take his word for it.

Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by kingkilr on Monday December 28, 2009 @05:35PM (#1019534)
There's a level of naivete to this line of reasoning that makes this amusing. Both Google and The Pirate Bay allow you to search for torrents. The critical element that's missing making what Google does criminal is Mens Rea. The Pirate Bay's got it, and Google doesn't.
Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by ErrantX on Monday December 28, 2009 @06:36PM (#1019661)
I want to highlight what another poster says: with "law" like this Mens Rea is crucial to the issue.

You can also find child porn on Google if you know how: but no one would consider them a distributor or a facilitator.

Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by tptacek on Monday December 28, 2009 @05:40PM (#1019550)
There's no reasonable comparison. Virtually every torrent index leads off with a link to Hollywood movie torrents.
Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by omouse on Monday December 28, 2009 @06:02PM (#1019581)
So does Google: http://i.imgur.com/Wy8cQ.png

Note the "quick" links to Hindi movies, movies & tv, music. How many of those are legal torrents?

Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by tptacek on Monday December 28, 2009 @06:22PM (#1019628)
I see a clear difference between editorial promotion of copyvio versus algorithmic promotion of copyvio, especially when the latter is made possible only by the former. You clearly disagree.
Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by dmnd on Monday December 28, 2009 @08:57PM (#1019869)
The implementation details of category or quick links shouldn't matter. How do you know that a particular torrent index's frontpage category links are not also algorithmically generated?
Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by tptacek on Monday December 28, 2009 @09:41PM (#1019932)
Because I'm neither willfully nor casually stupid.
Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by dmnd on Monday December 28, 2009 @10:10PM (#1019975)
Maybe I'm being pedantic, but you need a better explanation than you have offered olegk. Google wrote their quick link feature with the intent of applying it to all URLs they index. Torrent index sites categorise their content with the intent of applying it to all torrents they index.

If the vast majority of URLs on the internet were infringing copyright, would you still support Google's right to index them?

I wonder what percentage of an index needs to refer to infringing content before allowing users to search the index is considered facilitating infringement. This percentage seems to be (a large part of) what judges use as evidence of intent.

Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by omouse on Monday December 28, 2009 @07:11PM (#1019729)
Those "quick" links are editorial promotion by Google. Algorithms don't pick those links.
Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by tptacek on Monday December 28, 2009 @07:31PM (#1019762)
Quick links on websites are algorithmic.
Re:Torrent Search Engines Unlawful, U.S. Judge Says by omouse on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:58AM (#1020251)
I'm fairly certain they aren't. Do you mind if I ask if you've worked for Google?