News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by mschuster91 on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @12:16PM (#10192309)
Like with automobiles, where the law mandates fair availability of both manuals and spare parts, the electronics industry should be regulated.

I'd like to see:

1) in case there is any (F)OSS component in the firmware, the device manufacturer or distributor must provide the source of all (F)OSS components and a working build environment, for every firmware version available, as well as the neccessary tools/keys to upload said firmware to the device.

2) Disassembly and reassembly instruction manuals, as well as spare parts, should be provided nondiscriminately to both the manufacturer and any interested party. In case the device is "repaired" by swapping the defective unit with a working one, the manufacturer is exempt.

3) In case proprietary screws, glues etc. are used, the manufacturer must provide the same tools as used by official service at fair conditions.

4) All requirements above must be kept valid over the expected life time of the device, plus two years.

In case a manufacturer or distributor fails to adhere to these rules, the regulatory body must have the power to ban the product from sale until manufacturer or distributor comply.

Re:We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets by Silhouette on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @12:37PM (#10192436)
The trouble is, while it's easy to write that kind of wish list, it may simply not be commercially realistic to grant all your wishes. Imposing burdens on producing detailed technical documentation usable by anyone without the manufacturer's own in-house training could be a huge cost, for example, and totally blocking sales because someone objected to an unintentional omission in such documentation would be wildly disproportionate. That's before you even get to issues of trade secrets and the like.

What you can reasonably legislate/regulate is that manufacturers/suppliers can't actively impair third parties who want to provide alternative services and are able to do so to a sensible standard. Just blocking the kinds of legal shenanigans that these giants use to tie up small/local potential competitors would be a good start.