Not really. There's no reason you couldn't implement Facebook's core functionality with personal servers containing a profile at each node and a pub/sub (or even just pull) system connecting each node with its friends.
All data is encrypted and my server can be hosted anywhere (just as simple as setting up a WordPress instance).
My own "news feed" are a combination of all of the other nodes I'm subscribed to.
My problem with Disapora is that they push the "sign up to someone else's pod" rather than "install your personal pod".
It just feels like a multi-centralised model. Rather than one Facebook with my data, now there are 311 "Facebookesque" Diaspora Pods (as of today).
As much as people hate the idea, a WordPress like (PHP) application as a "personal server" would be successful. There are lots of hosting companies out there where you can get up and running for peanuts.
My aim would be for a simple install:
- Download software and upload to hosting company
- Enter MySQL auth details
- Choose local filesystem or third party (S3, DropBox, Google Drive, MS SkyDrive) with OAuth as the backing store (files stored encrypted).
- Finish
Then I would be able to subscribe to other friends and family personal servers, just like RSS feeds. Friends can access my own personal server through OAuth and leave comments on content. Those comments are echoed back in my private feed which is displayed in their merged news feed on their own app instance.
The technology is already there. It just needs someone who is damn good with PHP!
https://diasporafoundation.org/
Unfortunately it never really caught on.
- Is it possible to, say, log into my bank account, see my current balance, and set up bill pay?
- Can I order a pizza over IPNS?
- Can I do realtime chat?
Also, this article says we could use Namecoin and not rely on ICANN for DNS, however, you still need ICANN to distribute ip address to get connected to the internet in the first place. Or am I missing something?
I think that it should be possible to build hybrid centralized/decentralized sites with IPFS, with static public content being fully decentralized and sensitive information going through direct tunnels. Of course, the more decentralized your system the better.
As far as the IP system, yes we are unfortunately still reliant on ICANN being sensible about IP allocations, but the DNS system can be fully deprecated. I do know that there is a project out there to redo the IP system in a decentralized fashion but I can't recall its name right now.
The last one is a no. Well actually yes if you just poll a file, but that's not practical on a large scale. You need an external communication channel to implement that. It's possible to have that be fully distributed as well though, as in tox. You need this external communication channel to implement a lot of things anyway, so it would probably be part of the platform that forms around the idea of a distributed web.
Interesting to think about.
You won't have the full graph that Facebook does, but does that really matter? I suspect the best predictors of who your friends are would be people already in your network.
The idea is that every user owns their own content, not some central organization. Every user maintains a log of all of their actions, like an RSS feed. Every time they make a status update, that's an item. When they comment on someone else's status update, that's an item. Even when they just like something, it's an item. Each update of the action log would also have send ping to all friends, over some kind of distributed IM like tox. They already need an IM connection like that for messenger.
Given that information alone, anyone can reconstruct the activity of all their friends into a news feed, and post new content. You'd need a lot of client-side leverage, and the ability to upload to the IPFS network from the client, but all the dynamic information is there.
And there you have a fully distributed facebook clone. More resilient and privacy-sensitive and monopoly-averse than even tools like diaspora and statusnet.