We can stick with a tech metaphor: It would be like all tech companies and startups and VCs colluding to require a certain number of years in college before being willing to hire or fund anyone. And the universities would own any apps/code the kids wrote while they were in school. Obviously it would be ludicrously imbalanced for the top 18-year-olds in that situation to give up that much earning potential in exchange for a "gateway" to a profession that needs them anyway.
Sadly people really get into tribalism, and have much stronger ties to their college than they would to any local minor league team, so there's tremendous amounts of money in play to maintain the status quo.
I'm not sure what it is today, but "roster fillers" in the NFL were only making $50k/year not all that long ago. The average career length is 6 years according to the NFL, and 3.3 years according to the players' union. Decent players will make over 100k, but it's still a pretty short career.
The average salary is about $2 million/year. The median salary is about $1 million/year. The minimum salary for a first year player is over $400,000.
Here's an article with lots of details for 5 years ago: http://work.chron.com/much-money-nfl-player-make-year-2377.h...
And here are links to team-by-team numbers: http://www.spotrac.com/nfl/
$400k for a 3-year career is a lot better than the picture I was painting, thanks for the correction.
edit: link fix