News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alda: A music programming language by yellowapple on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @08:15PM (#10188944)
> From what I'm reading, Alda is essentially a MIDI file generator. It doesn't actually produce music, rather, it sends MIDI instructions for how to play music somewhere and leaves it up some other program to make the sounds.

As a fellow musician, I'd much rather some other program be involved in actually making the sounds. My workflow generally involves defining abstract voices (usually some traditional soprano/alto/tenor/baritone plus rhythm/percussion, though I do like to branch out of that sometimes) and reserving actual instrument/voice specifics for once the composition process is done with. I feel like the various other languages out there that "can actually make music internally" are more equivalent to making a physical piano roll than writing a score that any musician or group thereof - regardless of instrumentation - can perform.

This preference probably comes from my background in the drum & bugle corps and brass band worlds, where a brass ensemble will often be tasked with playing some piece originally intended for, say, a choir or chamber ensemble or organ. I've developed an appreciation of the ability to separate composition from instrumentation, and it looks like Alda is well suited to that, at least at first glance.

There are no comments on this comment yet.