Re:Patent Law Shouldn’t Block the Sale of Used Tech Products
by jdmichal on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:37AM
(#10186315)
I think your example with the watches is actually entirely non-relevant. I personally don't advocate for laws forcing companies to sell isolated parts to third-parties. It's certainly a nice thing for a company to do, and I would take that into consideration during a purchase.
To be analogous, the watch companies would need to be suing people for repairing their watches, perhaps by cannibalizing parts from other broken watches. I haven't heard of any watch makers doing that, and until they do, there is no attempt to subvert the doctrine of first-sale that we are seeing with the Lexmark case.
To be analogous, the watch companies would need to be suing people for repairing their watches, perhaps by cannibalizing parts from other broken watches. I haven't heard of any watch makers doing that, and until they do, there is no attempt to subvert the doctrine of first-sale that we are seeing with the Lexmark case.