News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by __d on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @09:35AM (#10185535)
The counter argument is that they do provide a benefit, by providing liquidity and/or making price discovery more efficient.

Whether it's "good" liquidity or not, and whether the discovered prices actually reflect true value or not, is a discussion that seems to fairly rapidly head down an acrimonious rathole.

Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by Frondo on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @10:33AM (#10185890)
I don't think it's acrimonious to say that no, that liquidity is not beneficial to society as a whole.

I struggle to see how any sector other than the financial sector would suffer if all trades happened once a second, or even once a minute. No process in the human world is going to change the value of a company quicker than that.

Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by tptacek on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @10:53AM (#10186017)
It's not "acrimonious", it's just wrong.

Liquidity keeps spreads narrow. Wide spreads are a tax paid by retail investors to a cabal of sell-side firms.

Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by Frondo on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:01AM (#10186078)
We don't need the amount of liquidity the HFT people say they're providing. No one benefits but them. They're not adding value to society.
Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by tptacek on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:02AM (#10186092)
So what's the RIGHT amount of tax we should be paying to commercial market-makers for the privilege of trading?

The residential real estate market is gigantic, a demonstrably functional piece of the US economy. Maybe the stock markets should work more like the real estate market. Forget about liquidity. Who needs it? Instead, we'll just pay seven percent of every transaction to an "agent".

Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by Frondo on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:04AM (#10186109)
Good question! I don't have an answer to that. I do know that the markets survived just fine before the HFT companies came along, and now that they're here, I don't see society as a whole any better off for their presence.

Maybe, without just saying "they provide liquidity" and leaving it at that, you can explain how the post-HFT world is better for anyone but the HFT companies?

Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by tptacek on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:07AM (#10186129)
Why don't I just let Vanguard, the most trusted firm in all of retail investing, explain that for me? Go look up with their Chief Investment Officer said about the impact HFT has on Vanguard's mutual funds.
Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by Frondo on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:11AM (#10186163)
Your reply reminds me of that saying, "Who do you believe, me or your lying eyes?"

If you can't explain it in pretty simple language why HFT-level liquidity is beneficial to society as a whole--to the people working in shops, managing restaurants, dealing in real estate, and on and on--then I'm inclined to think you're just trying to bluster about it.

Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by tptacek on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:13AM (#10186176)
That's a very self-righteous way of saying "I am not willing to perform a few Google searches and do a bit of reading".

Here, another hint: you can use the search box on the bottom of this page to find comments from me quoting Vanguard.

Either way, since you've accused me now of simply making things up to win arguments, I think I can let you off the hook. There's not much point in us discussing things further.

Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by Frondo on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:17AM (#10186199)
I don't think you're making things up.

I also don't think, if it's that simple and obviously good for society as a whole, that it should be that hard to simply explain your position.

Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by kasey_junk on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @01:38PM (#10187120)
I won't speak for him, but I think I can sum up a position that he would agree with very simply:

HFT has made trading cheaper for the vast majority of market participants. It has done this at the expense of the previous regime that was less efficient and more squalid.

Further, don't take my (or his) word for it. Listen to Vanguard which has a sterling reputation for caring for the interests of their clients who tend to be long term, small scale, investors and large pension/retirement funds.

http://www.cnbc.com/2014/04/25/vanguard-chief-defends-high-f...

Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by usefulcat on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:13AM (#10186180)
I tend to agree that the value of a company doesn't actually change substantially from one second to the next. But to focus on that is to ignore the value of having liquidity available. For an example of what can happen when there isn't enough liquidity, take a look at the graph of RSP on the morning of August 24th.

For a more detailed description of the mechanics and motivation behind market making, I recommend "A High Frequency Trader's Apology": https://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/hft_apology.html

If traders, be they high-frequency or otherwise, can't make money by making liquidity available, they won't do it. Less liquidity means wider spreads, which means higher costs especially for smaller transactions (i.e. individual investors).

You could reasonably argue that HFT has caused expenses to increase for large investors who need to buy or sell large volumes of shares. But to the extent that is true, it is like saying that large investors used to get on average an unreasonably good deal at the expense of their counter parties. As in any free market, an especially good price for one party is by definition an especially bad price for the other party.

Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by Marazan on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @09:59AM (#10185675)
They cannot add liquidity. They HFT can only make money when there are slower traders willing to buy and sell.

Thus, by definition the liquidity already has to exist (market participants wanting to buy and sell) for HFT's to profit.

Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by tptacek on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @10:54AM (#10186030)
Look at a market without market-makers. Housing is a good one. Houses sell only when there are "slow" traders willing to buy and sell. Have you ever bought or sold a house? Would you like the financial markets to be more like real estate?
Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by Frondo on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:03AM (#10186095)
The alternative to HFT is not the real estate market.

The alternative to HFT is how the markets operated for decades prior to HFT companies vacuuming money out of the system--that is, quite well, and with adequate liquidity, and with lots of money still being made.

Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by tptacek on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:04AM (#10186111)
The markets in the decades before HFT were crooked like a bucket of fish hooks! They were NOTORIOUSLY corrupt. Everyone was scamming everyone else. The entire market was a giant grift. Are you really sticking up for 1980s trading? Or have you just not done much research about how it worked?
Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by Frondo on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:06AM (#10186128)
Really? And now, with HFT, they're no longer crooked? If I remember right, in the 2000s we've seen a ton of crooked market scandals (fraudulently rated securities, LIBOR, etc etc). I don't see this relationship you're positing between HFTs and a non-corrupt trading market at all.
Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by tptacek on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:07AM (#10186135)
That's an illogical response.
Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by Frondo on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:08AM (#10186144)
You said: prior to HFTs the markets were corrupt, the entire market was a giant grift.

You implied that, without HFT companies, we'd be right back there, though I see now that you didn't explicitly say exactly that.

Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by tptacek on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:12AM (#10186169)
For your argument to make sense, all forms of corruption would need to have a single cause, and all interventions to reduce corruption would need to impact all forms of corruption. That's nonsensical and not a point I'm willing to engage further with.

I think we've pushed this thread far enough to the right margin of the page.

Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by Frondo on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @11:13AM (#10186179)
I get that you're passionate about HFTs, but what's that old saying? Fool me once, shame on — shame on you. Fool me — you can't get fooled again.
Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by Marazan on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @01:46PM (#10187174)
You seem to be accepting the premise that HFT algorithms a e acting as market makers.

I reject that premise. HFT algos are majoritarily run in markets with deep liquidity.

Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by auntienomen on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @03:24PM (#10187670)
Markets with lots of market-makers have more liquidity! Film at 11!
Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by tptacek on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @02:33PM (#10187428)
So do most market-making firms.
Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by toomuchtodo on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @05:37PM (#10188351)
I believe the question is: could the same market-making/liquidity be provided without the amount of profit being taken by HFT firms?
Re:High Frequency Trading Defined by vasilipupkin on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @10:19AM (#10185805)
this is incorrect. HFT can make money adding liquidity to a market that erroneously is lacking in liquidity ( mispricing )