News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Self-driving cars can be disabled with a laser pointer an... by krapp on Monday September 07, 2015 @08:59PM (#10183723)
Human drivers, on average, are not "disabled" by any of that. Distracted momentarily, sometimes, perhaps, but not disabled - city driving is replete with "bits of spray paint" and "funny sounds" and sometimes "women wearing short skirts." On average, human drivers manage a great deal of complexity without incident. We use the same visual acuity, adaptability and instincts to negotiate traffic as we did millennia ago to avoid predators and survive our climb up the food chain, and we're actually quite good at it, albeit obviously not perfect. Human drivers are capable of not mistaking the reflections of other cars for other cars, and know the difference between a cardboard box, a human being and another vehicle.

The bar is actually quite high, if you want to do better than humans on average.

Re:Self-driving cars can be disabled with a laser pointer an... by mikeash on Monday September 07, 2015 @09:01PM (#10183729)
Humans usually aren't disabled by that, but sometimes they are. How often is a human distracted by one of these things, and before they can recover they drive into an obstacle? It happens with great frequency.

And in this particular case, humans not only can be disabled with a laser pointer, but they can be disabled permanently, not just for that driving session, but for the rest of their lives. Can't swap out cameras in a human driver. Yet somehow this is not a crisis for manually-piloted cars.

Re:Self-driving cars can be disabled with a laser pointer an... by krapp on Monday September 07, 2015 @09:16PM (#10183771)
> It happens with great frequency.

I doubt it happens that often, but I can't back that up with numbers, and I can't be arsed to try.

But, humans can vary in their driving ability. In the case of autonomous cars, you would have to assume any flaw in one is shared by all. The problem isn't the laser pointers, or that humans can also be disabled by laser pointers, but that autonomous cars aren't yet smart enough to deal with errant signals. If all the autonomous cars can be stopped by an ever increasing list of simple conditions that (with a couple of exceptions, like a laser pointer in the eyes) wouldn't stop an average human driver, then it implies that the current state of the art does not nearly live up to the hype.

Re:Self-driving cars can be disabled with a laser pointer an... by mikeash on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @10:38AM (#10185929)
We can come up with a long list of simple conditions that wouldn't stop an average computer but would stop an average human, too. For example, a computer won't have any trouble driving for 48 hours without powering down, or with a stinging insect in the cabin.

That's not to say that computers are superior to humans. It's quite clear that the current state of the art in autonomous driving is way behind what humans can do. My point is simply that comparing scenarios which one can handle and the other cannot is not very informative.