Re:Poison-Injecting Robot Submarine Kills Sea Stars to Save ...
by milspec on Monday September 07, 2015 @09:09PM
(#10183749)
That does seem kind of neat, but it still doesn't make sense to me. You have to carry a poison supply that will run out. You need 12 mL per starfish.
Is that really more effective than just injecting lots of seawater? You could pump in seawater by the kL, not mL, and you'll never run out. The starfish will surely die after all bodily fluids have been washed out with seawater.
The other idea that comes to mind is a needle with an electrified tip. Depending on voltage and current, this kills in various different ways. You can heat the animal, zap the nerves, or (via electrolysis of salt) fill the animal with either chlorine or sodium hydroxide.
Re:Poison-Injecting Robot Submarine Kills Sea Stars to Save ...
by stinos on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @03:10AM
(#10184395)
Water or electricity don't lead to infection in other nearby starfish, which is probably needed here because it's going to be hard for a robot to find and kill all, or enough, of them. Which at the same point is also something to take care of: I hope the inventors checked the range of starfish etc, so that this won't lead to massive starfish death in places far away from the coral reef being meant to be protected.
Re:Poison-Injecting Robot Submarine Kills Sea Stars to Save ...
by dgemm on Monday September 07, 2015 @09:19PM
(#10183774)
Energy. Those are all energy intensive ideas.
Re:Poison-Injecting Robot Submarine Kills Sea Stars to Save ...
by milspec on Monday September 07, 2015 @10:43PM
(#10183951)
12 mL worth of battery ought to be able to handle most of those methods. That's about break-even, but better because you refill the same way you refill the computer and propulsion. Charge the battery and you're ready for more action, mess-free. If you can do the job with less than 12 mL of battery, it's a definite win.
Re:Poison-Injecting Robot Submarine Kills Sea Stars to Save ...
by theklub on Monday September 07, 2015 @03:29PM
(#10182679)
Countdown to "Indestructible starfish"
Re:Poison-Injecting Robot Submarine Kills Sea Stars to Save ...
by tinco on Monday September 07, 2015 @04:30PM
(#10182914)
Will Smith.. the last man on earth.. in New York.. has to sleep in a bath tub, because everything else is covered in huge spiky starfish. He doesn't have a dog.. the dogs were the first to go.
Re:Poison-Injecting Robot Submarine Kills Sea Stars to Save ...
by Sniffnoy on Monday September 07, 2015 @04:30PM
(#10182916)
Made into actual link to save a bit of trouble:
Re:Poison-Injecting Robot Submarine Kills Sea Stars to Save ...
by twic on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @05:29AM
(#10184731)
Thanks, and apologies to everyone for my mangling of the link when i posted it.
Re:Poison-Injecting Robot Submarine Kills Sea Stars to Save ...
by mmmBacon on Monday September 07, 2015 @07:27PM
(#10183468)
The poison is pretty cool for sure but the integration of all the tech here is pretty amazing. It's kind of incredible to think of all the complex systems here work together so well. When I saw the video all I could say is wow. It could be that we are near a "Cambrian Explosion" of autonomous devices like this. I was skeptical when I first heard that term applied to devices but this has me reconsidering.
www.int-res.com/articles/dao_oa/d097p085.pdf
So the injection basically amplifies specific members of the starfish's own microbiome to the point where they not only kill the starfish, but infect and kill its neighbours.
That is highly ingenious, and severely creepy.