Ask HN: A free "cell phone" for use within a few miles of home?
It seems to me that I should be able to buy a two-way radio that reaches a base station at home from at least a few miles away. I should be able to hook this radio up to my internet connection and do VoIP over my existing Skype/Gtalk account.
a) Cell phone-like mobile (battery operated) radio (encrypted ;-D ?)
b) Base station at home hooked up to broadband router.
c) One time cost of less than $300.
So:
1) Does it exist? (I'm guessing no, so why not?)
2) Would it be possible to do myself without spending $1k on hardware, hacking a bunch of custom hardware/software, and getting a ham radio license?
Update:
Long range cordless phones do seem to exist, but they're not cheap.
Voyager SS 2600 ($1500)
SN 258 ($300)
I'm also not sure they're allowed to be used in the US unlicensed.
(
8 comments
| 11 points
| on HN
)
That pretty much leaves you with having to get a business radio license ($260 per ten years minimum, plus possible additional fees), and on top of that you'll need a someone with a GROL ($60 fee plus testing fees) to maintain and operate it.
The only other option would be unlicensed VLF. This you could do, but there's two problems: the antennas for VLF are huge, and the available bandwidth is tiny. Ever used a 300 baud modem? Well, that screams compared to what you can get out of a VLF connection: 5 baud is a fast data rate in this band.
Those Voyager units use frequencies reserved for military use the United States. Using them in the US would be a good way to get yourself in a heap-o-trouble.
The problem you have is that for the range you want you need to be able to operate over the horizon. That means your receiver is going to be in one of the transmitter's diffraction zones, which means only a fraction of the transmitter's signal will get through. We do this all the time in radio, and we accomplish by throwing enough power at the problem to have a received signal strong enough to be demodulated even with diffraction losses. For the distance your looking for, you'll need about 25 watts minimum, way more than you can get away with in Part 15.
Use one as the base and get the audio in/out connected to your home PC audio in/out.
Hacking in a tone dialer ( http://is.gd/5EjWA ) might also be necessary.
-- MV
As for the successful commercialization, I think it involves too many components for ordinary people to be able to use it and customer support would be a nightmare.
There are unlicensed bands that are available, but again there may be restrictions similar to ham radio, and cost might also be a factor.
Just an idea, I'm not saying it's definitely a good one.
I can see this being useful if you don't currently have a cell phone. If you did, outside of cheaper international calls, it seems really redundant.
Plus if you ever traveled outside the signal radius you'll effectively have a big lump of plastic wasting space in your pockets (on top of everything else you carry).
All that said I think this would be a fun side-project and really with the rise of municipal broadband and services like Fon, I can see this being somewhat viable in the long-term.
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rabbit_(telecommunications)?w...