News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by CydeWeys on Sunday September 06, 2015 @05:58PM (#10179212)
It's so obvious it's amazing this hasn't already been a thing since the beginning of the obesity epidemic. Specific exercise instructions are more likely to be followed than a vague admonition to "exercise more". I wonder if gym memberships will be covered as care by health insurance plans? They're certainly a lot cheaper that hospital stays!
Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by 0xcde4c3db on Sunday September 06, 2015 @06:32PM (#10179335)
I think the problem is that the implementation process -- creating an actual exercise program -- is quite non-obvious. As far as I know, the studies that have been done on the dose-response curves of various exercises have reached somewhat inconsistent results, except that they consistently show significant inter-individual variability for a given tuple of type, dose, and outcome measure (NB: they do not generally show a single unified axis of exercise super-responders and non-responders, a common interpretation of such studies in the news media).

For the general population not trying to optimize performance in a specific sport, the nuts-and-bolts business of "what exercise should I do?" is fraught with bargeloads of pseudoscience, tribal lore, magical thinking, fad-chasing, and actively-amplified marketing nonsense.

And then if, despite the atmosphere of uncertainty, you convince yourself to try something and it doesn't work for you, that method's dedicated acolytes will waste no time in telling you that you must be doing it wrong, must by lying about something, are just looking for excuses to be lazy, and so on.

It's not really an environment that's shaped for success.

Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by Swizec on Sunday September 06, 2015 @09:55PM (#10179782)
> For the general population not trying to optimize performance in a specific sport,

Therein lies the solution. Pick a sport you enjoy, do it as many times a week as your schedule permits, but bend your schedule so it's at least twice.

Voila, 2+ hours of strenuous exercise per week.

Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by 0xcde4c3db on Sunday September 06, 2015 @10:19PM (#10179824)
How many sports must one try before being allowed to conclude that "a sport you enjoy" isn't in the cards?
Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by Swizec on Sunday September 06, 2015 @10:21PM (#10179835)
As many as it takes? I don't know ...

Really that's what P.E. is for, they were supposed to have exposed you to many sports so that you could find one you like.

I found boxing because I watched a few boxing movies. Then I decided to try and I liked it. Now here we are 6 odd years later and I'm training four times a week. Still no fights though, probably getting into that next year.

Surely you have some gut feeling about what you might enjoy? How do you find movies or tv shows that you enjoy watching? Or websites you enjoy visiting? How many tries did it take? How many tries did it take to find friends you enjoy hanging out with?

These aren't some deep dark secrets of life. It's just normal everyday stuff. Don't overthink it.

Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by 0xcde4c3db on Sunday September 06, 2015 @11:53PM (#10179999)
P.E. did expose me to many sports. I didn't really like any of them; some were more tolerable than others, but that's hardly equivalent to enjoyment. I don't dislike physical activity in itself (though it was practically impossible to maintain any consistent volume before my sleep apnea was treated), and I think I understand at an intellectual level why "people enjoy sports". But empirically the reward processes haven't happened for me.

Anyway, the reason I'm harping on this is that vague, noncommittal advice like "find a sport you enjoy" is exactly the sort of thing that a true exercise prescription ought to be able to avoid. Doctors don't pull out the Rx pad and write down "find an anticonvulsant that works for you".

Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by eru on Sunday September 06, 2015 @11:33PM (#10179952)
In that case, just bite the bullet and pick the sport you hate least.

If you want to minimize the commitment: weightlifting is pretty efficient time-wise and effective.

Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by Frozenlock on Sunday September 06, 2015 @07:47PM (#10179532)
> "It's so obvious it's amazing this hasn't already been a thing since the beginning of the obesity epidemic."

Why is that obvious? Because you think there's a link between being overweight and exercise?

Exercise does not promote weight loss. (You can do a quick google search if you don't believe it.)

The most important thing to influence weight loss is the nutrition.

On a related note, I find it borderline sadistic that we make fat people believe they are fat because they are lazy and don't exercise enough.

Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by Frondo on Sunday September 06, 2015 @09:16PM (#10179719)
That is an odd, bold claim to make, that exercise doesn't promote weight loss.

I'm at something of a loss to explain how, without changing my diet, but with adding 30-50 miles of cycling (plus a little jogging) a week, I've been losing around 5 pounds a month for the last six months.

Honest question time: if it isn't the exercise, what is it?

Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by cheepin on Sunday September 06, 2015 @09:47PM (#10179770)
Exercise clearly helps, but it all comes down to energy balance. You can eat less, or increase calories burned through exercise to generally get the scale heading in the right direction. The problem some people have is when exercise increases their appetite to the point where they continue consuming too many calories.

I looked at the article that OP referred to. It's main critique is using exercise instead of diet as a weight loss tactic. The point was that you don't need exercise to maintain a healthy weight as long as the energy balance is there.

On one end of the spectrum, athletes in certain sports can maintain a lean physique while eating insane quantities of calories. On the other end, maintaining a healthy bodyfat is possible in the absence of exercise by nutrition alone.

Exercise comes with its own set of benefits independent of bodyfat, and it sounds like you have chosen to meet your energy balance by increasing calories burned instead of decreasing caloric intake, but it's not the only strategy that can have success.

Sources:

"Can't outrun a bad diet" http://bjsm.bmj.com/content/49/15/967

Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by Swizec on Sunday September 06, 2015 @10:01PM (#10179801)
> The problem some people have is when exercise increases their appetite to the point where they continue consuming too many calories.

It's very difficult to overeat good exercise with good food.

If your idea of exercise is to sit around at the gym for an hour and do a couple of lifts, that's not gonna help. I've seen a lot of that. People go there for two hours, but only get like 15 minutes of real exercise done.

But if your idea of exercise is to go on a 10k run, or doing a boxing class for an hour ... well those are going to burn around 700 calories. That's a lot of calories for someone who's supposed to eat 2000 a day.

Eating 2700 calories (your normal 2000, plus the 700 you burned) is hard if you're not eating cake and stuff. I personally struggle every day to keep my weight from plummeting because the amounts of food I have to eat are astounding. Especially on the days when I do a 30km run (that burns 2500 calories).

Honestly, it's taken me over a year of sustained effort to train my metabolism to digest these sorts of quantities of food.

And yes, I am an edge case. My point is that you can outrun a bad diet. It will take a lot of running though.

PS: the biggest mistake people make is thinking that weight == health. You can be skinny and still super unhealthy.

Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by Frozenlock on Sunday September 06, 2015 @10:39PM (#10179854)
> (...) if you're not eating cake and stuff.

Ding ding ding. That's the nutrition part. I could easily eat that 700 extra calories by eating pizzas. Hell, I'd probably eat 900 extra calories after a big exercise. (But I would absolutely not run 30 km...)

The problem is that the people eating this stuff are continually being told that they need to exercise more. Then they get hungrier and eat the stuff that you can always eat more. They kill themselves on the treadmill and see absolutely no difference.

Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by Swizec on Sunday September 06, 2015 @11:20PM (#10179923)
Yeah, I see your point.

Is nutrition really that hard for people? It doesn't take much, just avoid the obviously bad stuff like candy, pastries, and anything non-dry that can stay fresh for over two weeks without freezing.

You don't even have to eschew sweet stuff, just opt for the artificial sweetener. They don't add hidden calories and [probably] won't give you cancer despite what the FUD says.

And in my experience, people who do eat the bad stuff, start craving more real foods when they exercise well. The body needs nutrients and it will ask for them. You just have to listen.

But I'm probably out of touch with how hard this is. It's been years since I started fixing my diet.

Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by dalore on Monday September 07, 2015 @10:07AM (#10181457)
You're putting down the weight lifters but I would argue that weights is better than cardio. With weights you build your strength, your muscles then consume more even when not exercising. Too much cardio starts burning your muscle giving you the skinny fat look.

Cardio takes a long time, an hour each day for 5 days is 5 hours. Can burn more at the weights. Unless you do sports that need endurance (MMA, boxing, rugby, …) you don’t need cardio. Strength training will increase your cardiovascular fitness above average.

Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by Swizec on Monday September 07, 2015 @12:25PM (#10181993)
Lifting is awesome. But you have to actually do it, not just sit around chatting or lifting at 40% your capacity like I see way too many people do.

If you aren't sweating, you aren't getting a workout.

Coincidentally cardio will make you better at lifting. When I recent got back to lifting for a few months I could power through 20 sets of compound lifts in an hour. By the time I change weight, I'm ready to go because my regenerative capacity is so quick (boxing will do that to you). Back when I was just lifting, 20 sets took over teo hours and the gains were very comparable.

I'd lift more, but it makes me slow.

Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by 0xcde4c3db on Monday September 07, 2015 @11:29AM (#10181763)
I don't think Swizec was trying to say that cardio is better than lifting, but rather that a high volume of exercise is needed to burn a lot of energy. A lot of people go to the gym, but mostly do it for the social meaning of "going to the gym" rather than actually using that time efficiently on a good workout.
Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by 15155 on Sunday September 06, 2015 @08:06PM (#10179582)
Exactly this.

Fat people are generally fat because of excess caloric intake. The amount of physical (aerobic) exercise needed to even burn off a can of Coke is incredible.

Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by harmarsupercar on Sunday September 06, 2015 @08:37PM (#10179642)
A can of coke contains about 155 calories. An average person can do practically anything which is reasonably considered exercise for 30 minutes and burn that off: http://www.health.harvard.edu/diet-and-weight-loss/calories-...

Hardly "incredible".

Research has shown that diet is more critical than activity in the occurrence of obesity, but that doesn't been that activity doesn't matter at all.

Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by Retric on Sunday September 06, 2015 @08:36PM (#10179638)
A coke is ~10% of your daily calorie needs.* It's not that exercise is ineffective it's junk food has stupid high calorie counts plus it's easy to digest. On top of that most Americans have an incredibly lazy lifestyle. If your extremely active and stick with actual food eating enough can feel like a chore.

PS: A coke is also 8 to 24 oz which is a fairly wide range.

Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by nathanvanfleet on Sunday September 06, 2015 @07:59PM (#10179562)
So many gyms are predatory and it just plainly irks me that they ask for such a high price or a long period of membership. It is valuable but I don't think their costs are so high.

I would definitely join a gym if it was deductible or even paid for or had state run facilities. But I guess that's a little too much to ask.

Re:Quebec doctors can now prescribe exercise by eru on Sunday September 06, 2015 @11:34PM (#10179954)
Go to the YMCA?